Amici Pizzeria

Amici Pizzeria - Table reservation

2387 NJ-36, 07716, Atlantic Highlands, US, United States Reservation
4.5 /5
434 Reviews

"The pizza was delicious with a nice thin, crispy crust and arrived hot. I really enjoyed it."

Details

Phone: +17328724333

Address: 2387 NJ-36, 07716, Atlantic Highlands, US, United States

Reservation, Booking

City: Atlantic Highlands

Website: https://www.amicipizzerianj.com/

Opening hours

Monday: 12:00-20:40

Wednesday: 12:00-20:40

Thursday: 12:00-20:40

Friday: 12:00-21:40

Saturday: 12:00-21:40

Sunday: 12:00-19:40

Statistics

Dishes: 10

Categories: 5

Reviews: 434


Address

Show Map

Reviews

Lindsey

5/5

I had the opportunity to try a slice of white pizza from this family-operated pizzeria at the Jersey Eats NJ Pizza Festival. It was the first slice I tried at the festival, and it was one of the most memorable. The crust was crispy yet soft, with no flop. The pizza was savory with perfect dollops of ricotta, and the cheese stayed put. It even had a unique crust topped with everything but the bagel seasoning. I usually don't go for white pizza, but I was drawn to try this one and I'm glad I did. The family running the pizzeria is friendly and proud of their business, which was evident in my interactions with them at the festival. I wish them all the best and hope to stop by for more pizza if...

Ivy

5/5

The cutest little restaurant where you are welcome with a warm greeting and a smile, really making it feel like home!All the sauces are scratch made, and you can really tell, the vodka sauce is my favorite! It’s fantastic on this gigantic garlic slider that they make, with real garlic butter none of that fake stuff! And the vodka sauce? Out of this world!You can get slices but getting a whole pie is the way to go! And if you want a more elevated experience, they have a dining room complete with artwork and lighting. And if you want a cute appetizer to start get the fried gnocchi!

Bev

4/5

The pizza at this restaurant is fantastic. The personal thin crust plain pizza is one of the best I've ever had. The meatballs and house sauce are so amazing that I would never try to make them myself. They are truly magical! If you are in the area during the summer, do not miss out on trying this place. If you live nearby and have not been here yet, you are missing out. By the way, I am just a customer and have no affiliation with the restaurant, but I highly recommend trying it. You will not be disappointed.

Kathleen

5/5

The food at this restaurant is amazing! One of my favorite dishes is the chicken marsala. The staff is willing to accommodate requests for keto-friendly options or any other modifications. Some of my top picks are the thin crust margherita pizza, the pig and fig salad, and don't forget to indulge in a freshly filled cannoli. It's a great spot for a gathering with family or friends. Plus, it's BYOB! Book a table now

Amelia

5/5

I worked with Melanie, the lovely owner of this charming restaurant, to plan my private event. The back area was cozy, private, and beautifully decorated. Not only that, but the food was incredibly authentic and my guests loved being able to bring their own drinks. I will definitely be hosting more events here in the future and would highly recommend it to others!

jason

5/5

Had a pizza party for my 4yo here. The pizza was outstanding! Especially the margherita. Staff was great and place is very family friendly. It's family owned and operated and it shows in the best ways. Would definitely return.

Jaime

5/5

Always spot on! Best place locally to order from. Hot, delicious, and always quick. I order all the time from here.

Mandy

5/5

Amazing food, amazing staff! Grilled chicken with fresh mozzarella balsamic is my fav! Def worth trying!! Book a table now

Lauren

5/5

The overall experience at this restaurant was fantastic, especially the mozzarella sticks and cannoli.

Gary

4/5

The pizza was delicious with a nice thin, crispy crust and arrived hot. I really enjoyed it.


Dishes

Garlic Bread With Cheese
Garlic Bread With Cheese

Chicken Caesar Wrap
Chicken Caesar Wrap

Sausage, Pepper Onion Wrap
Sausage, Pepper Onion Wrap

Sausage, Pepper Onion Hero
Sausage, Pepper Onion Hero

Run It Through The Garden
Run It Through The Garden

California Cheesesteak
California Cheesesteak

Sausage, Pepper Onion
Sausage, Pepper Onion

Godfather Cheesesteak
Godfather Cheesesteak

Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Buffalo Chicken Wrap

Hanga Loose Hawaiian
Hanga Loose Hawaiian