Spectacular!! Was traveling on business, first time in area. So happy to have found Arthur's! Started with pre dinner pickles/pepper tray yummy!! Entrée was Seafood Combo (grilled salmon, crabcake, and shrimp). Huge serving, and fully intended to take half for later but was so delicious, ended up gobbling up every last morsel! Then, with no room for dessert, nonetheless could not resist trying the inhouse made cheesecake with strawberries. Again, big portion, and eagerly gobbled all of it! I arrived early (5 ish pm) for dinner and had no trouble parking (in back) or getting a table. By 6pm, the place was getting rather busy. My dining experience at Arthur's was extraordinarily delicious sati...
We've never been to Arthur's Tavern before, so it was wild to see the tavern is packed on a Monday. We knew we were in for a great dinner. We ordered their Buffalo brisket burnt ends, a pastrami and just a classic cheese burger. The food really hit. The spot after a long work day. We're also happy to see that they support local craft breweries so thats awesome to see They have a fun and spacious bar/main seating area, a quieter and more traditional dining room upstairs and a large patio outside for the nicer days.
Never disappoints! You may need to wait a few minutes during rush hour but you will always leave satisfied. I called Arthurs tonight on my way home from the hospital after spending a long day there. It was shortly before closing, but I was able to get an order in and I’m happy to say that the quality of take-home food is just as good as the restaurant experience. Bummed that I forgot to ask for the pickles but always a great meal.
Another gem, this place if you are not a loca you won’t see it, however if you want to eat a great ribeye and chicken wings, this is the place 4 u. The tenderness of the steaks and the chicken wings are out of this world. I have been to very expensive restaurants where they claim their steak is the best, however this restaurant put them to shame. I will recommend this place.
Book a table now
Been coming here since the 90s by myself, with friends, with family bc I love steaks at least once a week. It just seems like after the pandemic, my delmonico has always tasted bland, uncooked; potatoes are bland uncooked. Very very very disappointed. I've always even recommended it a long time ago. Idk that I'll come back.
This is my go-to spot for a great steak dinner. Been going since I moved to Jersey in 2014. The Delmonico steak is THE BEST. It always tastes great. I make a good ribeye, but their steak is special. I love the roasted potato slices, as well. It’s worth the hour and a half drive, for me.
Like stepping into a classic joint from the 60s or 70s, Arthur’s combines great casual ambiance with friendly and fast service, serving thick steaks at reasonable prices.
Food is delicious. I recommend getting the 24oz steak medium. One of the best places to eat a good meal.
Book a table now
Great food and the restaurant history is fantastic A real icon that stood the test of time
Great place. Steak was excellent. Service was great.
