Request table reservation
You will maybe be redirected
"They forgot to include half of my order, and it was only two sandwiches."
Phone: +16318210500
Address: 6278 NY-25A, 11792, Wading River, US, United States
Reservation, Booking
City: Wading River
Monday: 05:30-13:40
Tuesday: 05:30-13:40
Wednesday: 05:30-13:40
Thursday: 05:30-13:40
Friday: 05:30-13:40
Saturday: 05:30-13:40
Sunday: 05:30-13:40
Dishes: 10
Categories: 5
Reviews: 362
The bagels and sandwiches here are quite good, but I have a significant issue with the inconsistent pricing for a side of bacon. Depending on who serves you, you might get a generous serving for $3 or just three slices for $8. There’s one woman, who I believe is possibly in a management position, who seems to set her own prices. On one occasion, my girlfriend and I ordered two bagels and a side of bacon, and she initially tried to charge us $18. When my girlfriend pointed out that wasn’t correct, she replied with, “you got bacon, but whatever,” and ended up charging us $12.
Stopped in with my daughter before school. Got a bacon egg and cheese in a roll, nice crispy bacon, no flimsy stuff! Also got a small coffee and my daughter got a donut and iced tea. The whole bill was just under $12. Coffee was fresh and hot. Lots of menu options here, I will come back for lunch sometime. GF bagel options. Boars head meats. Great salad menu and lots of pre-made deli type options. No shortage of options to satisfy everyone and the ladies behind the counter were friendly. I will return :
I visited this restaurant for the first time and ordered a roast beef hero with mayonnaise, lettuce, tomato, and provolone cheese. It was absolutely delicious! The $13.50 price for such a hearty sandwich is totally worth it. I can see myself coming back every day of the week. Keep up the great work, everyone—I’ll definitely be returning!
Bagel Buddies are my favorite! I ordered a dozen bagels through DoorDash, and when they didn’t have cinnamon raisin, they substituted it with French toast flavor instead—something that usually comes with an extra charge at most places! Thank you, Bagel Buddies! Book a table now
I enjoyed a tasty breakfast sandwich on a fresh bagel. However, the coffee was disappointing. I also found the price of $10 for a coffee and a bagel sandwich with two eggs and bacon to be a bit high.
Arrive early, as some of the specialty bagels might sell out later in the morning. My favorites are the sesame or everything bagel (typically available), paired with scallion cream cheese.
I had an incredible experience with both the service and the food here. They now accept credit cards too!
The wrap would have been much improved with some cheese added. Overall, it was rather flavorless. Book a table now
The bagels are outstanding, but I was disappointed with the Avocado Toast.
