Bagel Pantry

Bagel Pantry - Table reservation

577 Middlesex Ave, Metuchen, NJ, 08840, United States Reservation
4.4 /5
1045 Reviews

"Average bagels but incredibly overpriced.Organized chaos is the best way to describe their process.They charge customers if you (customer[s] request to have bagels cut; absolutely ridiculous."

Details

Phone: +17326323100

Address: 577 Middlesex Ave, Metuchen, NJ, 08840, United States

Reservation, Booking

City: Metuchen

Opening hours

Monday: 05:00-20:00

Tuesday: 05:00-20:00

Wednesday: 05:00-20:00

Thursday: 05:00-20:00

Friday: 05:00-20:00

Saturday: 05:00-18:00

Sunday: 05:00-15:00

Statistics

Dishes: 10

Categories: 5

Reviews: 1045


Address

Show Map

Reviews

L

3/5

Update 7/8/23They opened back up after several months (yrs? of being closed. Busy, small parking lot as always on a busy Rt 27 road.Ordered my usual pork roll (Taylor ham , egg, cheese $7. The bagel is still good has the tough crust on the outside, probably one of the best bagels in Middlesex County, however the sandwich is just ok. It was a single fried egg, with 2 thin slices of pork roll and barely any cheese. I felt like I was eating a plain bagel.Maybe just order your bagels to go and make your sandwiches at home yourself if you can.Lines can be long but they move. The person that takes your order is the same person who makes the sandwich, which keeps it organized and minimizes incorrec...

Ariel

1/5

I am downgrading my review of this restaurant from 5 stars to 1 star based on my experience today. When I walked in, the place was empty. I waited to be acknowledged, but I was completely ignored. Suddenly, a line started forming, and everyone else's orders were being taken while I felt invisible. I tried waving at the staff, but they continued to overlook me. It wasn't until the line cleared that an employee finally asked, “Can I help you?” I replied, “I’m not sure, can you?” He pointed out that there was a line, to which I responded that I was the first in line. He insisted that I wasn't, and when I suggested he check the cameras, he refused. Fortunately, another employee who had just come...

Yuvraj

4/5

This place has very high ratings for a reason, bagels were super soft and fresh. Many varieties of cream cheese and bagels.Parking is kinda limited in peak times but there is a big parking lot next to the shop. Good amount of indoor and outdoor seating available. Crew is super fast and helpful.There's also grab and go premade dessert and drinks. Bagel CC taste was just up to the point, no complaints. Vibe was chill and relaxing, good place to start the day. Tried:Walnut cc with sesame bagel(5 starts if you like sweet bagel cc)Would definitely visit again to try other CC flavors.

Het

4/5

I visited this place on the 4th of July, and it was quite busy. Fortunately, we managed to find a couple of open spots to sit and enjoy our meal. The service and food quality were excellent. We asked the cashier for recommendations for their most popular cream cheese and bagel, and we were not disappointed. Be sure to try the garlic bagel with olive pimento cream cheese and the everything bagel with jalapeño cream cheese! Book a table now

Ariel

5/5

This charming local spot is a must-visit for a delicious breakfast! They offer a fantastic selection of bagels and excellent breakfast sandwiches. The staff is consistently helpful and quick, the prices are fair, and the atmosphere is always welcoming. I highly recommend stopping by!

Kyle

4/5

This restaurant is definitely one of the more efficient bagel spots I've visited. I love that they offer an egg everything bagel. They seasoned both sides, which was tasty, but it ended up being a bit saltier than I would have preferred.

Oliver

5/5

I had a bacon, egg, and cheese on a French toast bagel with a sunny-side-up egg, and it was fantastic! I enjoyed my breakfast outside, and it made for a wonderful morning. If you haven't tried this yet, you absolutely need to!

Jes

5/5

I came in after working night shift. Convenient location off rt 27 with a parking lot on the side. I wanted a everything bagel with cream cheese and slices of lox. Indoor and outdoor table seating. 9.5/10 Book a table now

John

5/5

Always enjoy the bagels here. The flavors and textures are perfect and the service is quick and friendly. This is a quintessential Jersey bagel place, one I would be happy to go to daily if I could.

S

1/5

Average bagels but incredibly overpriced.Organized chaos is the best way to describe their process.They charge customers if you (customer[s] request to have bagels cut; absolutely ridiculous.


Dishes

Bagel With Cream Cheese
Bagel With Cream Cheese

Bagel With Special Cream Cheese
Bagel With Special Cream Cheese

Heart Healthy Grilled Chicken
Heart Healthy Grilled Chicken

Spanish Philly Cheesesteak
Spanish Philly Cheesesteak

Grilled Chicken Omelette
Grilled Chicken Omelette

Bagel With Smoked Salmon
Bagel With Smoked Salmon

Turkey Cheddar Omelette
Turkey Cheddar Omelette

Classic Grilled Cheese
Classic Grilled Cheese

Foraged Mushroom Pesto
Foraged Mushroom Pesto

Side Of Breakfast Meat
Side Of Breakfast Meat