It seems that Bagel Supreme doesn't have a toaster or toaster oven. Let me explain: I ordered an everything bagel toasted with cream cheese, but what I received was disappointing. It felt like the kid just lit a match to my bagel until the flame went out, claiming it was toasted. It shouldn't be that complicated, yet there are so many people in the food service industry who just don’t get it. How hard can it be? There are different levels of toasting—lightly toasted, medium toasted, and burnt. I won’t be returning again.
Everything went wrong during my visit. It seemed like ordering three bagels was a daunting task for the person who took my order. All three bagels came untoasted, despite her specifically asking if I wanted them toasted. One of the sandwiches was a disorganized mess, with egg on all of them even though I hadn’t requested it. I was extremely disappointed with this below-average experience. The bagels themselves are good, but the attention to detail was sadly lacking.
I had a fantastic experience at this place! The bagels are amazing, the service is warm and welcoming, and the coffee is top-notch. I visited with my uncle for breakfast, and even though I had just had a tooth extracted, the bagel was so incredibly soft—even when toasted—that I could enjoy it without any discomfort. I loved it so much that I returned the next day! These are, without a doubt, the best bagels I've had in New Jersey! Highly recommend!
Fantastic bagels! The service was friendly, and the coffee was excellent. My uncle and I visited for breakfast, and I had recently had a tooth extracted, so I needed something soft and easy to chew. To my surprise, the bagel was incredibly soft, even when toasted! I had no trouble eating it, and I even returned the next day for more! These are, without a doubt, the best bagels I’ve had in New Jersey!
Book a table now
Really nice little shop. I visited and had an egg and cheese on a plain bagel. Well prepared and nice, fresh bagel.Small shop. It was little hard to find a spot to wait and not be in someone’s way. But. Clearly a local favorite. There were many locals and regulars that made the atmosphere inviting.
I was quite disappointed with my experience. I placed an order over the phone, but they didn't have the bagel I wanted and ended up making it on something else without bothering to call me. I drove all the way from Linden to try this place, but unfortunately, the food did not meet my expectations.
Not coming back to this location , the other ones are better. They shorted me on cheese , I can't even taste it and they did nothing and said I saw it be put on :
The bagels are incredibly fresh and of excellent quality. All the food items are also very fresh. However, the interior is quite small for dining in.
Book a table now
Staff takes care of me! Bagels are fresh and stand the test of time when preserved properly.
This is our go-to breakfast spot. Nice menu with plenty of diner fair.
French Toasts With Egg & Taylor Ham
French Toasts With Bacon Or Sausage
Grilled Pork Sandwich With Egg
Pancakes With Bacon Or Sausage
Pancakes With Egg & Taylor Ham
Toasted Croissant With Butter
Chocolate Overdose Pancakes
Toasted Muffin With Butter
Breakfast Classic Sandwich
