It's been a while since I've visited Baldwin, but I recently checked out the Scouting area for Pizza Hunter's app. The customer service was outstanding—very friendly and helpful, making for a positive experience overall. I tried the Margherita pizza, which was excellent. The slice was large, and the crust was substantial. It performed well across the board. While I'm not sure the thick crust would win any competitions, it was definitely above average. I'm looking forward to going back soon to sample more slices.
The pizza was delicious! However, the potato skins were absolutely AMAZING! They had the ideal balance of potato and crispiness, and they even provided a generous portion of sour cream so you won’t run out. Check out the attached picture of those perfect potato skins and the nicely cut sour cream!
I just bought from here and decided to get a slice of pizza… that was the best decision I ever made because that slice reminded me of the childhood pizza around my block and it was was PHENOMENAL! Wow!
Really good food. Excellent pizza but this is not just a pizza joint. The food here is really good. Quality burgers, and great soups! Justin and his crew do a great job highly recommend.
Book a table now
My parents are OBSESSED with Baldwin Pizza, they only visit me so that they can stop in and get pies. The food is always great and the staff are awesome, especially Justin.
Oh my goodness... the Wodka Chicken Pam sandwich is like something crafted by the divine Italian grandmother. The sauce is incredible!
Great pizza and chicken dishes. Don't pass on the cannoli they're made fresh, keeping the shells crispy the best we've ever had!
Excellent pizza great place to enjoy ur favorites pizzas. Service allways best....
Book a table now
