Beenie's Ice Cream

Tried Beenies for the first time today and we were blown away. We're ice fanatics and some kind of picky. This is one of the best ice cream shops in NJ, hands down! The flavors are creative and funny, but also nostalgic and accessible s'mores, apple cider donut, waffle, cinnamon toast crunch. Among the three of us we had five flavors and each one was perfect. The s'mores is not just vanilla stuffed with some Graham cracker crumbs and chocolate; it is Graham Cracker ice cream with thick fins of Fudge, Marshmallow and chocolate scrap. Every bite tastes like a s'more. The banana tastes like real banana (not extract) and has a rib of real brown sugar. The maple bourbon bacon has bits of high qua...

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

What a beautiful place! I am vegan, and the staff was really knowledgeable and helpful about the great vegan options. I had a delicious coconut based on chocolate on a vegan waffle cone and it had perfect mouthfeel and taste! It is not easy to make big vegan ice cream when you are used to make milk ice creams, but Beenies has made it! Delicious!

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

Some of the best ice cream I have ever eaten in my life. They always have fun and creative flavors as well as knowledgeable staff. I look forward to coming here every time I am in town.

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

Unique, creative flavors. Efficient service. Even when the line is long, the staff handles it well. Now stop reading and go get some ice cream.

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

Great place, best ice cream I've ever had! I recommend cinnamon toast crunch or chocolate peanut butter cookie dough.

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply