We were staying at Kalahari Resort in the Poconos and we were looking for a place to get pizza. After searching google maps, we found Benny's. It was a about a 20 minute drive, and the reviews were good, so we took a chance on driving a little further. It was well worth the drive. We ordered a cheese pizza, a taco pizza, fries, and Chicken Marsala. The pizzas had amazing flavor, the fries were good, and the Chicken Marsala was excellent. The pizza crust was great, and the edge of the pizza was just right, not to thick, not thin, and it wasn't dried out like a lot of pizzas. We are from South Central PA, we have plenty of pizza restaurants in the area, but none of their pizzas compare to Benn...
We usually visit a different pizza spot when we arrive in the Poconos, but since our usual place was closed, we decided to give Benny's a try. I have to say, it was some of the best food I've ever had. The chicken parmesan dinner was incredible; the chicken was so tender it practically melted in your mouth. My wife's shrimp Alfredo had the best Alfredo sauce she's ever tasted. For a small family-run restaurant, the staff and the food felt like we were dining at a Michelin-starred restaurant. We’ll definitely be coming back next time.
If you're craving a cheese-loaded pizza with a perfectly sweet, freshly made sauce, this is the spot for you. During our trip to the Poconos, we explored several pizza places in the area and stumbled upon this hidden gem. The crust is nicely charred in all the right spots, and the Sicilian thick crust is simply fantastic. I absolutely loved it!
The food was fantastic! The owner was very nice and pleasant. We ordered a few slices and a sandwich. She gave us a side order of Pommes with every article. Definitely didn't have to. You can't beat what you see in the picture of $15.00!
Book a table now
Came for the pizza, but fell in love with the delicious Garlic Cheese Bread and Fries at Bennys Pizzeria in Poconos. Loved the small town vibes and connecting with the regulars.
Siri recommended a great pizza spot during my trip, and although it was a bit of a long drive off the main road, it was definitely worth it! The pizza was delicious—thank you!
Made a great pizza, on time and delicious. Very friendly and committed to serving the best Italian selections at reasonable prices, considering the current economic climate.
Benny serves delicious pizza and Stromboli. I always enjoy my meals there. The staff is friendly and courteous. I highly recommend stopping by for a bite to eat.
Book a table now
I have never had better pizza! The service is fantastic, the food is amazing, and anyone who thinks otherwise need to reevaluate their taste.
My favorite one is on RT# 715, where owner Luke makes a terrific pizza! Also Benny 's II his second and newest restaurant location RT# 115.
Special (Ham, Salami, Capicola, Turkey)
Linguini With White Or Red Clam Sauce
Cheesesteak Wrap With Sauce & Onions
Chicken Cheesesteak With Everything
Chicken Steak, Hot Sauce & Ranch
California Chicken Cheesesteak
Chicken Cheese Steak Stromboli
Sausage, Pepper & Onion Roll
Special Chicken Cheese Steak
Cheese Slice & French Fries
