I had the most amazing experience! I had a hard time ordering online so I was able to submit my order and pay over the phone. Special mention to the confirmation email! Sweets were delicious and freshly baked when I got them. The true reason for this review is that one of the workers delivered my desserts to the restaurant where I was having my event. It was a rainy Sunday morning and they had an issue with staffing but I truly appreciate the staff going above and beyond to make sure that I had my desserts in time. They were super friendly and I appreciate their efforts!
My wife and I spent the holidays in New York during a very chilly Christmas this past year. After doing some shopping at Macy's on Christmas Eve, we walked back to our hotel on E33rd Street near Park Avenue and stumbled upon this hidden gem of a bake shop. The pastries, cupcakes, and mini cheesecakes were absolutely outstanding. In fact, I returned that very night for more! The gentleman who was running the shop that evening was incredibly kind and added to the charming atmosphere of this delightful little bake shop.
They definitely keep their old brownies in stock from week to week. Their other store has always had good quality and fresh batches, but this store is clearly neglecting their product standards. Bought two brownies and this is what they looked like. It's clearly not fresh more like it's more than a week old. If this the case, I'm not sure how old the products are that they sell us. This is unacceptable and quite honestly a safety hazard.
The ube cupcake was delicious! The cake had a moist texture that wasn't overly crumbly or sweet. The frosting was a bit too sweet for my taste, and I would have liked it to have an even stronger ube flavor. The cashier was friendly and welcoming. There’s no indoor seating, but I believe they have a bench outside for warmer days.
Book a table now
We ordered a variety of cupcakes from Buttercup Bake Shop for an office party, and they were a huge hit! The selection of flavors was impressive, and the presentation was stunning. The taste was absolutely perfect—definitely a 10/10. We will definitely be ordering from them again!
Oh my gawd. The carrot cake cupcakes tasted just like my mom's carrot cake. Delicious! Hubby had the red velvet. I'm assuming it was good because he didn't share a bite. Had the lemon bar. The lemon was the perfect tartness and the crust was crumbly in the best way.
This business has excellent products, fresh, tasty, and affordable. I forgot my bosses birthday a few weeks ago and I ordered his cake the same day it was delivered. It was perfect and he was very happy.
Nice selection of really cute cupcakes. The Red Velvet is a personal favorite but today I tried the Espresso—delicious! Would love it if they served coffee to go with.
Book a table now
The s'mores cupcake wasn't good, dry and it becomes crumbs. I ordered a dulce de leche and they give a strawberry chocolate, wasn't bad better than the s'mores.
Ordered several different cupcakes and bars. All of the cupcakes were dry. The s'mores cupcakes had a weird smell and taste I threw it out. The bars were good.
Gluten Free Van/Choc (Vanilla Cake W/ Chocolate Buttercream)
Gluten Free Chocvan (Chocolate Cake W/ Vanilla Buttercream)
Gluten Free Van/Van (Vanilla Cupcake W/ Vanilla Icing)
Funfetti Rainbow Sprinkle Rice Krispy Treat
Raspberry Almond Marzipan (Staff Favorite)
Peanut Butter Jelly Bar *Staff Favorite*
Gluten Free Blondie Choc Chip Gooey Bar
Quadruple Chocolate Ganache Cheesecake
Apple Crumb (Our 2Nd Staff Favorite)
Berry Captain Crunch Cereal Treat
