Calogero's

Calogero's - Table reservation

919 Franklin Ave, 11530, Garden City, United States Reservation
2438 Reviews 4.4

"They skillfully installed a new panel and outlet for my generator."

Details

Phone: +15162942922

Address: 919 Franklin Ave, 11530, Garden City, United States

Reservation, Booking

City: Garden City

Website: http://www.calogerosgardencity.com/

Opening hours

Tuesday: 11:30-22:00

Wednesday: 11:30-22:00

Thursday: 11:30-22:00

Friday: 11:30-23:00

Saturday: 16:00-23:00

Sunday: 15:00-21:00

Statistics

Dishes: 10

Categories: 5

Reviews: 2438


Address

Show Map

Reviews

5 /5 Rating

Staying in a nearby hotel, and evening being since and warm, made me feel like I wanted to walk a bit to find something healthy, delicious but also not overpriced to eat. Google reviews is what I normally use and Calogero’s caught my eye as they had pretty high score already and were open until 10pm. It was already past 8:15pm so I decided to give it a try. Nice people, very friendly, good food and quick service made me feel they deserve 5 stars. If you are looking for an extraordinary experience, this is not the place but it hits all points when it comes to good food in a cozy atmosphere. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

5 /5 Rating

I had lunch here with some friends last week; it's our usual go-to spot. We all ordered the same dish, which is also one of our favorites—the chicken panini. It was a delicious meal featuring grilled chicken, roasted red peppers, arugula, fresh mozzarella, and pesto. I opted for the restaurant's homemade fries as my side, which are actually chips, and they were quite filling—I ended up with plenty of leftovers! The service was excellent and very attentive. We’re looking forward to coming back in the fall to enjoy lunch outside! Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

5 /5 Rating

Can I just say that choosing Calageros for our wedding shower was a fantastic choice! The outside tent was beautiful. It was very nicely decorated with hanging floral decor and wreaths. The waiting staff gave us five service the entire time. The sangria is delicious and fresh. The food is also outstanding, very fresh and full of flavor. We will definitely return at some point in the future!

5 /5 Rating

First time at this restaurant and was not disappointed. Our party of 7 was seated promptly and the service was attentive all night. Salads were fresh and crisp, Manhattan chowder was tasty and the seafood fra diavolo was delicious. All the portions were plentiful and we thoroughly enjoyed our meals! Book a table now

5 /5 Rating

This restaurant is an amazing place, and I went to dinner with my girlfriend, and it was amazing food, amazing service... and the waiting staff is very accommodating. Even when I ran late, I let the restaurant know and the people were understanding the phone! 11/10 has to eat here!

5 /5 Rating

Big Family dinner at night before the wedding. The staff and the owner stayed with us while we overhauled our visit, but food and continental beverages were accumulated, so they didn't make it too much. A great atmosphere. Excellent food from a varied menu. Go.

4 /5 Rating

Excellent Italian good, fresh pasta. Don’t discount the chicken parm! It was excellent as was the short rib ragu with pappardelle fresh pasta. Service was very good and nicely mannered.

4 /5 Rating

Small portions and a little high priced. Nice outdoor seating makes it nice. Food is good quality just need more on $30 plates 2 adults 2 children was over $150 Book a table now

5 /5 Rating

Excellent selection of foods. Monk fish was cooked for perfection. Very nice experience. Service was fast and attentive. Very recommended.

5 /5 Rating

They skillfully installed a new panel and outlet for my generator.


Dishes

Make Your Own Sicilian Pizza With 3 Or More Toppings
Make Your Own Sicilian Pizza With 3 Or More Toppings

Tomato, Mozzarella, Red Onion And Basil Crostini
Tomato, Mozzarella, Red Onion And Basil Crostini

Make Your Own Sicilian Pizza With 1/2 Topping
Make Your Own Sicilian Pizza With 1/2 Topping

Make Your Own Sicilian Pizza With 2 Toppings
Make Your Own Sicilian Pizza With 2 Toppings

Make Your Own Pizza With 3 Or More Toppings
Make Your Own Pizza With 3 Or More Toppings

Make Your Own Sicilian Pizza With 1 Topping
Make Your Own Sicilian Pizza With 1 Topping

Warm Chocolate Cake And Vanilla Ice Cream
Warm Chocolate Cake And Vanilla Ice Cream

Whipped Ricotta, Truffle Honey, Arugula
Whipped Ricotta, Truffle Honey, Arugula

18" Large Upside Down Sicilian Pizza
18" Large Upside Down Sicilian Pizza

Make Your Own Pizza With 1/2 Topping
Make Your Own Pizza With 1/2 Topping