Carlo's Gourmet Pizzeria, Caterers

I typically enjoy the food at this restaurant, but my experience with the gluten-free chicken parm was disappointing. The chicken was extremely thin and overcooked, almost splintering. The sauce on the pasta was watery and running off. It was a shame that we drove all the way from Eatontown for the food. I'm not sure if we'll make that trip again. This used to be my go-to spot for gluten-free Italian food, but after giving it another chance on October 2nd, I was thoroughly disappointed. The pasta was undercooked, the sauce was unappetizing, and the meatballs were rubbery and lacked flavor. The gluten-free garlic bread was simply a toasted hot dog roll for $10. It was a horrible experience an...

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

Amazing experience! From the moment I called to place my order, the staff's energy on the phone was top-notch. My order was ready when I arrived, thanks to the friendly staff. The food was delicious, especially the large calzone that I shared with my partner. I couldn't even take a picture of it because it was so good! They offer gluten-free options, but since I love gluten, I didn't check them out. The parking right in front of the store was convenient as well.

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

The food was average, but the prices were quite high. We paid $60 for two pizzas with vegetable toppings, which seemed excessive. The markup was excessive! The pizza was mediocre, but we appreciated that they allowed for takeaway orders and had gluten-free options available.

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

The new owners appear to be friendly. I only tried a slice of pizza, so I can't comment on the overall food quality, but the pizza lacked flavor. It had too little sauce for my preference.

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

I am pregnant and I felt guilty calling multiple times for my order being incorrect. However, their customer service is truly exceptional and the staff is extremely kind!

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply