Carmenta's

Carmenta's - Table reservation

50 Starr St, Brooklyn, United States Reservation
4.5 /5
3777 Reviews

"The Rigatoni at this restaurant was exceptional. The pasta was freshly made and cooked to perfection, and the sauce was delicious and perfectly portioned."

Details

Phone: +17186765003

Address: 50 Starr St, Brooklyn, United States

Reservation, Booking

City: Brooklyn

Website: https://www.carmentasnyc.com/

Opening hours

Tuesday: 12:00-20:30

Wednesday: 12:00-20:30

Thursday: 12:00-20:30

Friday: 12:00-20:30

Saturday: 12:00-20:30

Sunday: 12:00-20:30

Statistics

Dishes: 10

Categories: 5

Reviews: 3777


Address

Show Map

Reviews

G

1/5

The Spicy Eggplant Parmesan was disappointing. The sauce and bread were great, but the eggplant seemed to be of poor quality. This used to be the best place ever, but the quality has declined since around the first quarter of 2023. However, they still have amazing recipes. The Turkey Salsa Verde Sandwich is usually unique and incredible, but it hasn't been as good lately. The pasta used to be less greasy in the past, so I stopped ordering it. The rice balls are consistently fantastic, as is the sauce.

Jason

3/5

The Chicken Parmesan and Spicy Meatball Parmesan were both pretty good, but they could have used more marinara sauce. I was happy I ordered a side of marinara because it was pretty good. Unfortunately, the Spaghetti with Beef Bolognese was not good. The pasta was overcooked and the beef was shredded, giving it a strange, soft texture. Everything else was good though.

Connor

4/5

Italian deli located on the corner of Starr and Wilson creates elevated sandwiches and pasta staples. The style and preparation of the sandwich though.. reminded me of Harry and Ida’s before they closed in the east village. Very high quality ingredients, attention to detail like the ricotta and pesto. Fantastic bread. A must try! ???

Allie

5/5

The chicken parm, the turkey sandwich and all their pastas are really delicious. I would say I have gone over a half dozen times and it never disappoints. It is pricey some would think because it’s essentially a take out spot but it’s high quality and one of the best in the neighborhood. Book a table now

Aya

5/5

Best pasta in bushwick, delicious texture, I LOVE IT. Slightly pricey but worth every bite. My favorite pasta ? here is the pappardelle and oh, their lemon ? yard is also one of the most delicious I’ve ever tried. ? recommend.Food: 5/5

Steven

5/5

Great delivery food. Arrived quickly crispy arancini and hot pasta. Only complaint is pricey, but hey, life in the big city huh? Food was definitely better than some fancier Italian spots.

Monserrat

4/5

Large pasta portions.The sammys feel fresh and very adequately positioned to bread sized.The Cesar salad is especially delicious, no anchovies. The artichokes app is also worth a mention!

Kyle

5/5

This place was amazing! Good portion sizes at a fair price and delicious pasta!My wife had the Penne Meat Sauce and I had the rigatoni with vodka sauce. Can't recommend enough! Book a table now

Eugenia

5/5

We ordered the rigatoni, meatball parm, and rice balls. Everything was delicious particularly the rigatoni. We will definitely be ordering from here again!

Olivia

5/5

The Rigatoni at this restaurant was exceptional. The pasta was freshly made and cooked to perfection, and the sauce was delicious and perfectly portioned.


Dishes

Delicate Squash, Brie, Orange Vinaigrette , Toasted Hazelnuts, Pickled Onions
Delicate Squash, Brie, Orange Vinaigrette , Toasted Hazelnuts, Pickled Onions

Fried Kennebeck Potatoes/ Herb Garlic Mayo (Contains Nuts)
Fried Kennebeck Potatoes/ Herb Garlic Mayo (Contains Nuts)

Marinated Gigande Beans; Ramps/Lemon/Calabrian Chilies
Marinated Gigande Beans; Ramps/Lemon/Calabrian Chilies

Penne Pasta/ Chicken Sausage/ Roasted Tomatoes
Penne Pasta/ Chicken Sausage/ Roasted Tomatoes

Chicken Cutlets And Wild Arugula Pesto*
Chicken Cutlets And Wild Arugula Pesto*

Lumache With Fennel Sausage Ragu
Lumache With Fennel Sausage Ragu

Rice Balls And Tomato Sauce*
Rice Balls And Tomato Sauce*

Turkey Salsa Verde Sandwich
Turkey Salsa Verde Sandwich

Torres Mediterranean Herbs*
Torres Mediterranean Herbs*

Mafalde W/ Beef Bolognese
Mafalde W/ Beef Bolognese