Came to this location for the first time last week to place a cake order based on all the reviews. The owner Paul was very friendly and accommodating. I ordered a sheet cake for a family get together for my Mother and Father in-laws 90th birthdays. His store had so many ice cream options I didn't think Carvel normally offered. I would absolutely bring my family here for ice cream even if it's a little out of my way. I picked up my cake yesterday and it was perfect for our get together. I recommend this Carvel shop
I would give this place negative 100 stars if i could. 2 months ago i ordered shakes for me and a colleague and we got food poisoning from the turned milk they use. We spoke to them and they tried to offer us gift cards in replacement for getting us sick. I spoke to Paul the owner and so tonight i decided to give them a second chance and this is what they delivered to me, see attached pic and inside one of the shakes is a plastic wrapper, as seen in another pic. Oh guess
Every time I go to this store, I'm blown away by how kind every single person who works there is. They are generous, and the service is always amazing. I live near a closer Carvel than this one, but I will ALWAYS make the trip to W Islip to go to this specific store.
Best Carvel on Long Island. Whenever we are hungry for Carvel cake, root beer floats or flying saucers, we travel to west islip Carvel. The man who owns it is so nice and kind to our family for many years. His Carvel always tastes the best. 5 stars, best Carvel!!!
Book a table now
If I could have a last meal, it would be carvel.Enough said Service: Takeaway Meal type: Other Price per person: $30–50 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
This store specifically has been handling all my birthday cakes since 15 years ago. To this day they have not disappointed. Best ice-cream cakes ever
Hot summer days beat thing to have is soft serve cone. EVERYONE was super friendly and sweet. Love going there.
Definitely one of the largest and well stocked carvels I've ever been to! And you can't beat the service!
Book a table now
Always a great establishment and Paul is super friendly. Ice cream sandwiches are delicious.
Great Carvel, big location with large selection. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 3
Sorbet Scooped (Vegan Dairy-Free Dessert)
Strawberry Shortcake Sundae Dasher
Square Ice Cream Celebration Cake
Round Ice Cream Celebration Cake
Sheet Ice Cream Celebration Cake
Strawberry Banana Sundae Dasher
Chocolate Banana Sundae Dasher
Deluxe Flying Saucers (6-Pack)
Bananas Foster Sundae Dasher
Ice Cream Quart (Soft Serve)
