Very disappointed with this store. I asked my daughter to pick up fudgie the whale for me and when she brought it to me it was a mini cake a lot smaller than the box it was in. Called the store owner and he said he can make it whatever size and charge whatever price he wanted. I usually go to west orange where fudgie fills the box. I will never go to Madison carvel again. He is a ripoff. Also the crunchies were soft and the fudge was not the same. I would have thought all carvel cakes would be the same at all stores. I would recommend going to a different store.
Total disappointment. I have been a long time customer of Carvel going back 40 years in NY. We just moved to N.J. and I was so happy to have a Carvel I. Madison NJ. I ordered an Icecream cake for 12 people. It said it serves 14 to 18. When we opened itup, everyone laughed. It was $35!!!! Look at the pic (hopefully I can upload it . Stay away from this place. Total rip off. (It was 1 inch thick. it served 12. Everyone had a tiny piece. Total joke.
I was looking to buy an ice cream cake for my son for his birthday and the site said they close at 10:30pm which was perfect. Well we arrive and it’s only 9:20pm and they are closed with no updated signs and such; I was very disappointed after driving 20 minutes to get there when all the other carvel locations state online they close by 9:30pm. Never coming here again
I ordered the crazy for crunchies cake for my sons birthday. It was supposed to serve up to 12 people. It cost me $53.00. The cake was a tiny round cake that barely fed 6 people. There was nothing special about this cake. It was a total rip off. I'll never order from here again. RIP OFF!!!
Book a table now
I moved to Jersey 5 years ago from Colorado and I've been looking for a great authentic Mexican restaurant. This is it! Best Mexican food in Jersey! AMAZING!! I'll definitely be back.
Stingy with the ice cream and toppings compared to other Carvels. Didn't use the plastic drip/sprinkle catcher on my cone like other places.
Awesome ice cream and Kind staff. Also quick service. This Carvel location is better than other Carvel locations I been to.
That was really good. They layered the toppings and sauces well, good proportions. Will be ordering again!
Book a table now
This location cheats you on the portion size and overcharges. The South Orange Carvel is much better.
it was actually pretty good. not nearly enough toppings though.
Sorbet Scooped (Vegan Dairy-Free Dessert)
Chocolate Cover Strawberry Sundae Dasher
Strawberries Crunches Sundae Dasher
Strawberry Shortcake Sundae Dasher
Square Ice Cream Celebration Cake
Round Ice Cream Celebration Cake
Sheet Ice Cream Celebration Cake
Pumpkin Cheesecake Sundae Dasher
Gluten Free Crunch Sundae Dasher
Cinnamon Crunches Sundae Dasher
