The Stromboli was decent, but the large pizza was a disappointing, soggy disaster. The toppings looked unappetizing, with the supreme pizza featuring only a few pepperonis and everything else appearing a dull greyish-green. I also ordered broccoli cheddar bites and waffle fries, both of which were so soggy they fell apart and tasted like they were microwaved. It was so unappetizing that it went straight in the trash. I won’t be ordering from here again. I really can’t understand how anyone has had a good experience—this was, without a doubt, the worst pizza I’ve ever had.
Pizza is good. However service is not. Guy felt the need to restock the sides machine while I'm standing there.. waiting for my order . That was so be sitting on stove.Not a hello. Not a welcome.. not an acknowledgment at all.. just putting cans into an already decently stocked cooler.Then a guy comes from the back to finally ask what I need. First gentleman couldn't have cared less what I needed.Kind of wierd.
We always order pizza from Castello unless they’re closed. Their cheese is incredibly rich and has the perfect stretch that mozzarella should have. We’ve tried the Meat Amanti, Spinach Florentine, Bianca, Margherita, Stromboli, and more, and I've never been disappointed. The pizzas are always hot and delicious. Plus, the staff is a great group of guys!
Everything arrived quickly and was piping hot! The Margherita Pizza had the perfect portion size, with buttery and savory dough that's utterly addictive. The Corn Nuggets are truly unique! The Baklava was incredibly juicy and flaky. I would have taken pictures, but it was all gone in no time, lol!
Book a table now
This is the best Italian food in the area! The Meatball (10 Roll was absolutely AMAZING... the cheese is high-quality and bread melts in your mouth. Cant say enough good things-this is my go-to spot now :
The pizza was decent. It had a good amount of toppings, but it didn't taste particularly fresh or flavorful. However, the crust was really nice. The chicken fingers with honey mustard were outstanding!
The extra large pizza was massive and the toppings were fresh and sooo delicious! The cheese pull is phenomenal! Hands down best pizza and pasta I've had in Columbus
Pizza was soooo good! We had the Margarita and I order Cheese pizza with chicken, spinach, and mushrooms. Loved that they are open so late!!!
Book a table now
The food is great, and the pizza is exceptional. I haven't tried much yet, but everything has been good so far!
"This is a fantastic little pizza place with incredible food and excellent customer service!"
Thick Crust Cheese Pizza Create Your Own
X- Large 16 Hand-Tossed Cheese Pizza
Small 10 Hand-Tossed Cheese Pizza
Large 14 Hand-Tossed Cheese Pizza
Create Your Own X-Large 16 Pizza
Meatballs With Sauce And Cheese
Beef Pepperoni 16 Pizza X-Large
Create Your Own Large 14 Pizza
Beef Pepperoni 12 Pizza Medium
Beef Pepperoni 14 Pizza Large
