I found a Pearl, when I found Catch Oyster Bar!!! Weather I come in with friends, or I sit at the bar and meet new ones the CATCH always a great day. Love the Oyster menu, the selection of fresh oysters is the best I have ever seen. Their take on Oysters Rock, and their roasted oysters are both amazing and should not be missed. They make hands down the best fish and chips, ever!! The Tuna bites are another must have. So many amazing items so little time ...... You will have to go back to try them all. Friendly, welcoming staff with a business owner who works in his business. He may take your order, he might make your drink, there is a good chance he even cooked your food. Lets all support ni...
The restaurant has a very small and somewhat cramped atmosphere, making it less than ideal for a romantic date night. However, the oysters are exceptional – some of the best I've ever tasted, incredibly fresh and pristine. While the rest of the menu is also quite good, the oysters truly steal the show and are worth the visit alone. They offer an impressive selection of local oysters, along with a great variety of local beers and cocktails. It would be a fantastic spot for after-work drinks if it weren't so narrow. Overall, the food is fantastic, the drinks are excellent, and the staff is incredibly friendly and attentive.
My wife and I visited Catch on 7/2 Saturday afternoon. Everything was spot on starting with the stuffed clams. Nice flavor . The lobster roll was perfect, served warm and buttery. The Flounder sand which was the BEST I have had in a very long time. The portion was generous , fresh flavor , just perfection. Thank you very much. Makes us appreciate coming back to visit Patchogue. We will be back. 4.5Stars!!
My wife and I split the Hook, Line, and Sinker platter and it was plenty of food for both of us. Just as importantly, it was all delicious! All of the components tasted incredibly fresh and you could tell they were prepared with care rather than being mass-produced. Reasonable prices and a friendly atmosphere. I would highly recommend!
Book a table now
The oysters here are truly outstanding—absolutely top-notch. The restaurant has a cozy atmosphere, accommodating around 15 guests. I recommend sitting at the bar to fully enjoy the experience; you can watch the impressive shucking, sizzling, and simmering preparation right before your eyes.
Popped in on a whim. Had some north shore oysters with their mignonette sauce, a sweet compliment to the briney nature of the oysters. Tried their spin on oysters Rockefeller called Fried Oysters Rock. A very unique spin on a classic that did not disappoint, definitely going back for more.
Great food tap beer selections, we tried three different IPA and it was excellent. The food was awesome, we ordered crabcake slider and chowder, Tai Calamari and Hook Line Sinker, definitely going back again.
I returned and tried the lobster roll this time, and I loved it! The atmosphere is great, and once again, Rubi was wonderful. The food is incredible. This place is a must-visit!
Book a table now
Ridiculously great food. THEY BEST OYSTER SHUCKING IN LONG ISLAND. Very good prices. There is always just one waiter/waitress so make sure to leave a generous tip!
**Service:** Dine-in
**Meal Type:** Dinner
**Price per Person:** $20–30
**Food Rating:** 5/5
**Service Rating:** 5/5
**Atmosphere Rating:** 5/5
