My wife and I recently bought a frozen Shepherd's Pie from our local Market Basket, and we had high hopes given the price. Unfortunately, we were extremely disappointed; it was easily one of the worst, if not the worst, Shepherd's Pies we've ever had. While the pie did have a decent amount of filling, it was incredibly dry and completely lacked flavor. The meat had a strange mushy texture, and the corn was still crunchy. We cooked the pie for 100 minutes to reach the recommended internal temperature of 170 degrees in the center, and then we had to broil it for an additional 2 minutes just to get some browning on top. I definitely do not recommend their frozen pies, but I can’t comment on the...
Their pie shop is Centerville is fantastic and offers tasty pies but my review is for the their frozen Shepard's pie I got from stop and shop. These other reviews seem aggressive regarding the frozen pies, I thought it was very tasty, my only suggestion is that it could use another filling with the beef and corn, maybe some carrots or peas? Maybe add both! I ended up cooking some peas on the side and just added it to my pie. Crust was very good. A bit pricey but it's no more expensive than Marie Callenders pies at the store and IMO much tastier. Cheers.
I have been ordering the Shepard pie on a regular basis and I've never been disappointed. On my last order there was an issue with my address and when I spoke with the Centerville pie people it was like talking with a neighbor. My shipment arrived within 2 days. It's always packed with dry ice and frozen solid. It's totally worth the price to have it shipped. Thank you Oprah and Centervlille pie company!
I bought 3 boxes of the mini’s. Big mistake!! I’m an old born and bred southern/country Gal and these were not good!! Dry, tasteless, and chicken was tough!! I tried 3 of the mini’s trying to give them the benefit of the doubt but it was all i could do to stomach them. Threw the rest in trash. The regular pie maybe better but I will never know. I will go back to the lady that makes them in my area.
Book a table now
My husband and I just enjoyed one of your famous Chicken Pies! Omg! Absolutely delicious, so flavorful, just a delightful Chicken pie. I served it with fresh cooked carrots and peas and cranberry sauce. We live in CT and were happy to find your pies in t he freezer section of our Big Y supermarket. We will certainly purchase it again, and will visit your shop when on the Cape.
The chicken pot pie that we bought frozen at Market Basket was inedible.Baked as directed, the bottom crust was raw, and the top crust was half cooked. Several giant chunks of chicken were tough and dry and wouldn’t even cut with a knife. Four slices of carrot throughout the pie. No flavor at all.
Mrs. Buckley and I had a chicken pie tonight, and it was awesome! We cooked it a little over 90 minutes, perfect! Our oven is slow! Great crust, gravy, and crust! What a great philosophy the company has!
Pie has hydrogenated oils and fructose corn syrupCan you use healthier ingrrdients?My family does not eat any foods that contain these ingredientsWould love to buy from your company.
Book a table now
Have been searching for a wonderful chicken pie. Found IT. Thank you. If I had one suggestion please a little more gravy in the pie. Wonderful amount of white meat. Delicious.
Amazing lunch and pie!! My first time here and it has been the best meal of my vacation, I came very close to licking my plate clean!
Two Eggs With Cheese On Portuguese Sweet Roll
French Toast With Choice Of Meat
Bacon, Sausage, Ham Or Linguiça
Hash Brown With One Egg Toast
One Egg, Toast, Homefries
