If your at Cherry Grove ocean walk in Fire Island, Cherry Grove Pizza is the place to go. I greeted by the really nice waitress, who had a smile the whole time. She also made sure I got everything I needed and checked up on me to make sure a comfortable amount of times. I asked what she recommended, so I decided to go with the chicken hero. It was delicious, hot sub, 12’ and fulfilling. The cheese was on point and the bread was not hard on the ends and the chicken was perfect as expected. Great cooks. The other waitress was very nice, as I got up from my table she asked if everything was okay and if needed anything. I did not only enjoy my food but the service inside and out was 5star. I lov...
Cherry Grove food spots, this restaurant is a must-visit. Serving delicious pizza and other Italian dishes until late, it's perfect for satisfying late-night cravings. The spaghetti was exactly what my tired body needed after a night of partying. Our server was charming and attentive, demonstrating patience throughout our meal. Live music is also featured on some nights, so be sure to catch Sushi Roll if you can!
The best pizza on Fire Island can be found at Tear's Off restaurant. It is worth the trip to Kirschhain for their delicious pizza compared to other options on the island. Their triple chocolate mousse cake is decadent and delicious. The Oma Sicilian pizza with peppers, spinach, and pepperoni is also a must-try and absolutely delicious.
"This place exudes a comforting vibe, from its casual atmosphere to the plastic utensils that bring a touch of nostalgia. The pizza and food were delicious, though not the absolute best I've ever had. Nonetheless, it hit the spot and came at a reasonable price. Our waitress was exceptionally friendly as well."
Book a table now
BEST pizza on fire island hands down. It’s worth it to go to cherry grove for this pizza over the pizza in the pines. I love the triple chocolate mousse cake too v decadent. The grandma sicilian pizza with added onions, spinach, and pepperoni is YUMMYYYY.
Our server Michael is so attentive and kind. I the pizza is amazing every single time without fail whether you sit down or take it to go or even better, have a few pies delivered right on the beach.
Me and my gf LOVE the pizza rolls – fresh, garlicky spinach and pepperoni, seasoned to perfection, with a tangy, sweet, and scrumptious marinara sauce for dipping. Get one of each, at least!
The pizza at this restaurant is fantastic, with generous portions and toppings. The meatballs were also delicious. The staff is very attentive and friendly. I have dined here twice.
Book a table now
The pizza here is consistently delicious. We were so hungry that we forgot to snap any pictures of the food. The restaurant offers fantastic specials throughout the week.
Pizza was amazing. Generous portions and topping. Meatballs where great. Staff is very attentive and fun/nice. Ate here twice.
Neapolitano Special Pizza Slice
Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza Slice
Siciliano Marinara Pizza Slice
Grandma Sicilian Cheese Pizza
Reese's Peanut Butter Cup Pie
Fresh Mozzarella Tomato Salad
Siciliano Special Pizza Slice
Napoletano Cheese Pizza Slice
Lettuce Tomato Salad Catering
Grandma Sicilian Pizza Slice
