We stopped at this pizzeria after a trip to a nearby farm. The owner Tony was really nice and let us laugh. While waiting for our cake, he offered us garlic bread and it was delicious. The pizza was great and when I asked Tony if he could break my twenty to leave a tip, he said not to worry about it, but he said I can do the dishes if I wanted. I definitely recommend stopping next time in Colts Neck. Note: Tony has autograph images hanging from local athletes and celebrities everywhere. Makes an interesting and fun time.
The service was excellent, and our server had a great sense of humor. There's a charming little courtyard where you can dine outside, which was lovely. The only downside was the nearby road, but that's not something Colt's Neck Pizza can control. They allow only one person inside at a time, demonstrating that they take COVID regulations seriously. We ordered the cheese garlic bread and cheese pizza, both of which were absolutely delicious! Overall, we had a fantastic experience and enjoyed some wonderful food!
The most handsome man in the world makes excellent pizza. I asked if I could park my car at the edge of his parking lot for a few days with a "for sale" sign on it. I gave him a $50 check, and he paid me cash once the car sold. It sold in two days, and I told him it was fine to deposit the check. However, the check was never deposited, so I inquired about it twice. It seems that money isn’t a priority for Tony—he’s meant for something greater!
We’ve found our new favorite pizza spot! As soon as we walked in, the mouthwatering aroma of delicious pizza captivated us. The staff member who assisted us was incredibly kind and treated us to garlic bread, salad, and cookies! Everything we tried was fantastic and fresh. We can’t wait to explore more items on the menu. Thank you!
Book a table now
The BEST PIZZA on the East Coast, you can find in Colts Neck, NJ!!! Everything on the menu is amazing!!!! All the food is fresh and very flavorable!!! The owner, Tony is so nice, friendly, and kind!!! You have to try the pizza and antipasto salad that's is my favorite!!!
i go here a lot dont know why everyone is saying overpriced? i think theyre all old and havnt bought pizza since 1940 times have changed every pizza place ive been to in my life is just about equal to this guys prices. love the food great place!
Best pizza and subs around! Tony and family are great, they will take care of your hunger for tasty Italian and keep you coming back!
