Coney Island Pizza

40 Paterson-Hamburg Turnpike, Riverdale, 07457, United States Of America Reservation
4.3 /5
5844 Reviews

"Tasty wood fired pizza. We always enjoy ordering several pies and everyone gets to try a different slice."

Details

Phone: +19737250990

Address: 40 Paterson-Hamburg Turnpike, Riverdale, 07457, United States Of America

Reservation, Booking

City: Riverdale

Website: http://coneyislandwoodfiredpizza.com/

Opening hours

Tuesday: 04:00 -20:00

Wednesday: 04:00 -20:00

Thursday: 04:00 -20:00

Friday: 11:30 -21:00

Saturday: 11:30 -21:00

Sunday: 12:00 -20:00

Statistics

Dishes: 10

Categories: 5

Reviews: 5844


Address

Show Map

Reviews

Carlos

5/5

My fiancé and I spontaneously decided to have a date night at this restaurant while my stepdaughter was at All-Star TKD Fitness for her taekwondo class next door. Despite it being a Monday night, there were some customers dining in, but we were promptly seated and served. We were in and out in 45 minutes, just in time to catch the end of my stepdaughter's class. I posted pictures of the delicious pizzas we ordered. My fiancé had the meatball pie, and I had the buffalo chicken pie. The pizzas were small enough to enjoy on our own but hearty enough to share along with a salad or other light starter. My fiancé enjoyed the buffalo chicken slice I shared with her so much that she wanted another s...

Sandra

5/5

Though slightly more expensive than other options, this restaurant is definitely worth the price! The pizza is cooked to perfection in their wood-fired ovens, giving it just the right amount of that delicious wood stove flavor. The ingredients are incredibly fresh, particularly the vegetables which were crisp and flavorful. The pizza never gets soggy in the middle, which is a huge plus. Highly recommended!

Emily

4/5

Love wood fired pizza and have ordered from here many times on Grubhub. It's usually good however several times the crust has been burnt. I love the Popeye pie and Margherita. I haven't eaten inside the restaurant so can't speak on service or ambiance however good food when not burnt!

Nick

4/5

The pizza at this restaurant is really good and unique. It's not your typical pizza place - they don't have slices, just 12 different whole pies to choose from. There's a good variety of options and overall it's a solid spot. Definitely worth a try. Book a table now

Richard

1/5

The pizza is good. The business is horrible. You never know if there going to decide to deliver on any given day, or sometimes the just won't open at all. It is without a doubt the worst service and business model I have ever seen.

Anna

5/5

They do two for Tuesday's where you can get a margarita pie for free with another pizza purchase. That's the deal that brought us in and now we order all the time! The pizza is delicious!

Chris

4/5

When you've got Pizza Exhaustion and you need something New Different that comes with a crust around it think of Coney Island Wood Fired Pizza!

Debbie

5/5

Great pizza and very friendly service. Miss dining in and do wish they would reopen as a dine in restaurant again vs only doing takeout. Book a table now

Brian

5/5

Best pizza ever !!! Service is great and pizza sauce and dough are on point !!! Brooklyn style pizza I was the best .

Marc

5/5

Tasty wood fired pizza. We always enjoy ordering several pies and everyone gets to try a different slice.


Dishes

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Homemade Mozzarella Caprese
Homemade Mozzarella Caprese

Traditional Margherita Pies
Traditional Margherita Pies

Organic Farm Raised Salmon
Organic Farm Raised Salmon

Buffalo Chicken Flatbread
Buffalo Chicken Flatbread

Flatbread Hummus Platter
Flatbread Hummus Platter

Sping Chi Chi Pea Salad
Sping Chi Chi Pea Salad

Wood Fired Potato Skins
Wood Fired Potato Skins

Chipotle Ranch Chicken
Chipotle Ranch Chicken

Wood Fired Hot Wings
Wood Fired Hot Wings