Cusumano

Cusumano - Table reservation

432 S Main St, Old Forge, 18518-1609, United States Of America Reservation
4.2 /5
1094 Reviews

"Great food, awesome drinks, and the friendly staff was beyond accommodating. Will definitely be back!"

Details

Phone: +15704574166

Address: 432 S Main St, Old Forge, 18518-1609, United States Of America

Reservation, Booking

City: Old Forge

Opening hours

Wednesday: 17:00-21:00

Thursday: 17:00-21:00

Friday: 17:00-22:00

Saturday: 17:00-22:00

Sunday: 17:00-21:00

Statistics

Dishes: 10

Categories: 5

Reviews: 1094


Address

Show Map

Reviews

Matthew

1/5

Let me corroborate some of these previous reviews before the owner accuses another unsatisfied customer of having dementia. 1. Table for 7, reservation made 2 days in advance, for 7pm Saturday. Why am I standing in the foyer at 7:30pm, getting tripped over by drunk waitresses and 12-year-old busboys? That 's not what reservation means. Maybe I 'm hallucinating, like the rest of these reviewers. 2. When we were finally seated, they didn 't bring us water for another half hour. I can 't tell you how excited I was for my water ration, like a prisoner. But even prisoners get bread, right? Guess again. Bread wouldn 't come out until 8:30. A couple one-inch-thick slices of baguette for a table of...

tia

1/5

Absolutely atrocious. I made a reservation for 7 people at 7pm to celebrate my birthday and my fiancé’s new job with my family. We were not seated until almost 8pm. We waited another 20 minutes for water and to have our order taken. They brought out 3 slices of bread for a table of 7 people. Our salads (with iceberg lettuce and a $5 upcharge for Caesar) came out at 8:45 and we asked for more bread. They brought us bread that was frozen in the middle and couldn 't even be sliced all the way through properly. At this point, we decided not to even wait for our meals, as everything was already so terrible it wasn 't worth it. It was also so loud in the restaurant that we could barely even talk t...

K

4/5

Cute Italian eatery located in Old Forge. The atmosphere and service was great. Very friendly and helpful. We got pizza and some appetizers. The pizza is old forge style, which is almost like a Sicilian style, but with a mix of mozzarella and cooper. Not too my liking, but it's very popular here. Old Forge says they are the pizza capital of the world, which I'm not sure I agree with, but I can see why people would enjoy it. The drinks were great and the tiramisu was awesome as well. Definitely will go back and try some of the other dishes. There's a big parking lot right next door that you can drop the car off and walk around a bit. There are a few restaurants in the immediate area that all...

Roam61241961509

1/5

It's a robbery to charge for every soda that a person drinks nowadays. Especially when you are waiting over 40 minutes for pizza. We spent $20 alone in soda.4.00 a soda tge glas was as big as an irish coffee! And then they come around with a dessert tray. not telling you how much anything is. We paid $33. For two pieces of coconut cake and a crem brule we hD pizza $96 00 that is horrible for 3 people.. Book a table now

barbara

2/5

Way overpriced for what you get. Drink prices are New York City prices. Won’t be back there again. First place we’ve ever been that told us we could not have a second basket of bread because they were rationing it! There were 5 of us dining. Crazy! Waitress and bus boy were very nice.

Aidan

5/5

We ordered Thanksgiving Dinner for our family, and let me tell you we may never cook again! Everything was delicious.. top notch! And they provided detailed, step by step instructions for reheating. Highly recommend!!!!

Mary

5/5

Great place.. We actually stopped just for takeout and a drink.. They found us a table even though we didn't have a reservation and the service was amazing...We will be going back to have an actual meal there soon..

Paige

5/5

Food is always excellent! Espresso martinis are my go-to here! They make a mean one The tiramisu is delicioussssss Book a table now

Vincent

5/5

Great American Italian food, best part you can split since they give way to much food... or plenty of leftovers

Dawn

5/5

Great food, awesome drinks, and the friendly staff was beyond accommodating. Will definitely be back!


Dishes

Shrimp Cocktail
Shrimp Cocktail

Veal Marsala
Veal Marsala

House Salad
House Salad

Pepperoni And Cheese Stromboli
Pepperoni And Cheese Stromboli

Sausage And Pepper Stromboli
Sausage And Pepper Stromboli

Potato Pancakes
Potato Pancakes

Arancini Limone
Arancini Limone

White Pizza
White Pizza

House Salad
House Salad

White Pizza
White Pizza