If you find yourself in the Hicksville area, you absolutely must stop by Di Maggio's Pizzeria for a classic slice with a unique twist. Tucked away in a modest shopping plaza, this pizzeria has everything you could want. As soon as you step inside, you'll understand why it’s a beloved local spot. You might even start humming your favorite Billy Joel song—after all, this was his favorite hangout as a kid! Now, let’s talk about the pizza: it’s always fresh, and you won't see any old pies sitting around like at some other places, thanks to the bustling traffic and quick turnover. I tried a Buffalo slice, and the addition of sesame seeds on the crust was a delightful surprise, bringing back memor...
The pizza at Di Maggio's Pizzeria is always fresh—unlike other places where pies can sit too long due to slow customer turnover. I had the Buffalo pizza, which featured an unexpected twist: sesame seeds on the crust. This delightful addition reminded me of amazing pizzerias from my childhood in Brooklyn.
For dessert, I treated myself to "Sal’s Sensational Italian Ice," and it was exceptional. I haven't had such delicious Italian ice since my days at Court Pastry Shop on Court Street in Brooklyn, a beloved establishment for 75 years. Sal and his team truly excel in crafting Italian ice.
This spot should definitely be your top choice for Italian ice; it's miles ahead of the competition—like...
I can't believe I haven't visited Di Maggio's Pizzeria in years, and now I know I won't be returning! I ordered the Shrimp Fra Diavolo along with a side of meatballs, but what I got were poorly cooked meatballs and a plate of pasta with tomato sauce. There wasn't a single shrimp in sight! I wasted $25 on that meal. While inflation is one thing, this felt like a total rip-off! On a side note, I wasn't aware that the place is under new ownership, but given the poor service, I doubt they'll be around for long.
I can't believe how disappointing my recent visit to Di Maggio's Pizzeria was. After years away, I was eager to return but ended up regretting it. I ordered Shrimp Fra Diavolo and a side of meatballs, but what I got was overcooked meatballs and a plate of pasta with tomato sauce—no shrimp at all! For $25, it felt like a total rip-off. And to add to that, I didn't realize the restaurant was under new ownership, but given the poor service, I'm not sure they'll be around for long.
Book a table now
The new owners have unfortunately raised the prices, but the quality has also declined. We used to love their calzones, but tonight they were prepared by someone new. They were smaller, the dough was rolled thinner, and there was significantly more mozzarella compared to the amount of ricotta. Plus, the ricotta itself tasted different. After years of visiting, I think it might be time for us to find a new place.
Outstanding New York-style pizza with an impressive variety and some of the best crust I've ever tasted. It reminds me of home. The staff is very friendly and the service is quick as well.
I've been ordering from Di Maggio's Pizzeria for years, and it has consistently offered great taste at reasonable prices. I especially love the sesame crust! The menu is fantastic too!
The new owners have done a magnificent job in re-opening this classic pizza joint! The new menu is awesome and I love the pizza they are making. I 100% recommend this establishment.
Book a table now
I've been ordering from Di Maggio's Pizzeria for years, and it's consistently delicious and affordably priced. I absolutely love the sesame crust!
The best sauce on Long Island. The staff is extremely friendly and always puts a smile on our faces. Highly recommended
Half-Spinach And Artichoke Pizza
Tomato Mozzarella Salad Large
Tomato Mozzarella Salad Small
Buffalo Chicken Salad Small
Buffalo Chicken Salad Large
Half-Penne Alla Vodka Pizza
Chicken Lettuce Tomato Hero
Grilled Chicken Salad Small
Grilled Chicken Salad Large
Half- Chicken Cutlet Pizza
