This restaurant is one of my husband’s favorites and he bragged nonstop about the pizzas. W/O further ado, we stopped here for lunch on our way to our hotel 6/18/24). Service could have been better; however I think there was only one server one cook. I’ll give our server the benefit of a doubt. I ordered the Garlic Bread Parmesan $5.50) and that was delish! My husband I shared a large Pizza $22) and I absolutely *L O V E* thin crust! The pizza *WAS* the $hit! Beverages aren’t free refills $2.75); however I had a feeling they weren’t. Biggest disappointment is they don’t accept credit/debit cards. Cash Checks Only; luckily I have cash. Agreed, it is a tad bit pricey; the way I look it is, it’...
Thin Bar Pie’s Not worth it... AMBIANCE: 2 out of 5 We entered by the bar and the smell wasn't the greatest! So I’d recommend to sit in the dining room area and although clean, it needs a facelift! SERVICE: 2 out of 5 She bailed before cashing us out. The clam pie took too long so she definitely showed she did not want to be there. FOOD: 3 out of 5 -Onion rings: Too greasy -Cheese Bar Pie: Tasty Pizza without the guilt -Pepperoni Bar Pie: The pepperoni is not high quality and the cup/scoop pepperoni is better so they should switch! -Clam Casino Bar Pie: Fresh clams definitely! Not out of a can!
I actually haven't been there since the 1990's. I checked MapQuest to see if they still existed and how long it would take to drive there. That said, I used to go there ALL the time. The pizza is not only very reasonably priced but I would challenge anyone to find better pizza than Eddie's. Especially thin crust, likely the best thin crust in the country if not the world ! I truly look forward to once again tasting Eddie's pizza, it's been way too long !
I love thin crust pizza, but this crust was ridiculously thin and crunchy, cracker like. There wasn't enough cheese or sauce. Neither I nor my partner liked it, will not return for pizza, maybe other dishes though $27 for a pasta dish is a bit steep even if if it does contain some type of meat. The service was quick and friendly.
Book a table now
What can I say!?! There’s a reason this place has been around for almost 100 years! You’ll never find a bar pie as thin and delicious as Eddie’s! Lorraine is the most loyal server you’ll ever meet. Being served by her adds to the experience.
We ordered the Eddie's Special large pizza to take out. This is definitely one of the best thin crusted pizza I've had in New York! There's a reason why this place has been around for almost a century!
Excellent food and service in a very downplayed atmosphere. Go for the best thin crust pizza anywhere, always. Back again for another tasty visit.
First time we ordered pizza from this place, it was very nice. We will go back for more.
Book a table now
Haven't been there in Yrs the bar pies were like I had them yrs ago
Can tell from the outside but the pizza is one of the best in NHP
Pepper, Sausage, Potato Egg Hero
Spaghetti W/Sausage Or Meatballs
Spaghetti W/Garlic, Oil Broccoli
Spaghetti W/Bolognese Sauce
Spaghetti W/Marinara Sauce
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana
