I recently hosted my daughter's birthday party at Emmy Squared Pizza: Midtown West in New York, and I couldn't have asked for a better experience! From the moment I reached out to inquire about hosting a party, Kelsey, the general manager, went above and beyond to make sure every detail was perfect. Planning a party for over 20 guests can be overwhelming, but Kelsey made the process seamless and stress-free. She was incredibly helpful in suggesting menu options that would cater to everyone's tastes and preferences. Her expertise in table setting and decoration truly elevated the ambiance of the restaurant, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere for guests of all ages. On the day of the part...
The Colony pizza was quite good. The pepperoni was cooked perfectly and crispy. The jalapeños added a nice kick to the pizza. My wife had a gluten free margherita pie with dairy free cheese. She said the crust and sauce were excellent, but the cheese alternative was bland and gummy. Great signature cocktails, too.
This was a wonderful place for our dinner. We have been to Emily Squared before and this time it did not disappoint. The pizza was spot on. My friend and shared a Margarita pizza. The crust was divine. We had hoped to add some hamburger but it was not offered as an add-on. The pizza was wonderful anyway.
We had a wonderful experience at this restaurant. As out-of-town visitors attending the Met, we were pleased with the delicious food and the friendly service from our server.
Book a table now
We went for the $30 burger and it was a disappointment. The meat was completely overcooked and dry. The waiter didn't ask about the cooking term of the burger.
Had Caesars salad “classic” pie. Both were good (but prefer NY style slices). Did not realize till later in the day how much sodium I must have consumed!
Service was terribly slow. I was also surprised to hear loud vacuuming going on in the dining area while people were trying to enjoy an evening out.
Overall, it was a fantastic experience, although the prices were a bit steep for the portion sizes.
Book a table now
The food was excellent! I would definitely go back. We ordered vodka and Margherita pizza.
Good place to have a simple dinner near Lincoln Center.
