Several plusses but a few minuses as well. The dinner rolls were divine!! Most appetizers were great but the calamari (usually my fave) was such a let down. The texture was awesome but the actual taste was disappointingly bland and somewhat egg-y. Crab cake was raved about and the burrata was pretty good. I had the halibut (catch of the day) and my partner got the 8oz strip. Neither was a hit. But others at the table had Branzino, Salmon and Chicken and those got rave reviews. Inside is pretty dark (speakeasy vibe) and due to the location of our table, the beautiful waterfront view was obscured. That too was a letdown b/c ambiance as a big part of why we chose this restaurant. I 'll try agai...
We went here to celebrate a birthday. The appetizers were out of this world. We ordered fried calamari and baked clams, and ordered a special which a bruschetta that was toasted, with burrata, prosciutto, fig and drizzled with honey. For main course, we ordered the lamb chops which were cooked to perfection. The farro and cherry drizzle were superb.
Service was very courteous and attentive. Appetizer and main course was delicious ! However, dessert was a little disappointing; molten lava cake was literally just a brownie, and the warm apple crisp was extremely tart. I would’ve gave food 5 stars if the dessert was better. Overall, a great restaurant with a good appetizer and main course!
We had a lovely dinner here for our anniversary. The food, service, ambiance everything was excellent. Our waiter was awesome. Because I must have indicated on the reservation that it was our anniversary, the waiter brought over a sparkler and insisted that we have dessert on them. We will definitely go back.
Book a table now
Gatsby's is so good that I was actually there once for lunch and once for dinner over these past five days. The weather was perfect for sitting outside, directly next to the pond. Food and service, as always, was excellent.
These guys were terrific. My daughter and son go there often and when my wife and I accompanied them to Gatsby’s they were more than accommodating. The menu was varied and the food great. Would go again and again
Always a wonderful experience at Gatsby's Landing Roslyn. The food is exceptional and extremely fresh. The only thing better than the food is the service.
Friendly attentive staff, beautiful surroundings, variety of food options, even for vegetarians. Will definitely go back!
Book a table now
A wonderful experience and meal. I brought my family here for my wife’s birthday. Definitely going back.
Our experience was really nice. All the people that work there were so attentive. The food was yummy.
