Good Fellows Pizza Italian Specialties is not what it used to be. I drove 45 minutes for their subs, only to end up with a basically empty sandwich—minimal meat and way too much lettuce. They were once known for packing their sandwiches with plenty of meat, but it seems those days are gone. On top of that, the price jumped from $14 to $20. I’m not sure I’ll be coming back anytime soon.
I visited today at 3:00 PM and was charged $20 for a half-filled sandwich. I know their menu well, which is why I made the long drive from Flemington and sat in traffic on the way back. If I wanted just a regular sandwich, I’d make one myself at home. Before receiving my sandwich, I even asked for a knife to...
The presentation of the food was impressive, but the taste was just average. It felt overpriced for what we received. However, the dessert was a different matter—it was excellent.
To the owner: I can't respond to your inquiry directly, but I wanted to provide some feedback on the food so you can make improvements. The pasta was overcooked; it seemed like it had been reheated in the microwave for too long. The marinara sauce, which is meant to be a spicier and more flavorful option, was unexpectedly watered down.
The sandwich had decent quality meat, but it was skimpy on the slices. The provolone cheese lacked any flavor, and the onion was chopped too finely. There was an excessive amount...
I’ve been a regular customer here, often ordering multiple times a week. Today, I ordered the penne alla vodka with chicken cutlets for $18.95 in a small container, and they told me it always comes in the small size. Prices have gone up, and they just lost a loyal customer. What a rip-off! By the way, the last few times my order came in a large container, but they basically accused me of lying. They said they never use the large size and clearly don’t care about losing my business. It’s really disappointing—I won’t be ordering from them again.
I had an outstanding experience with the customer service at this restaurant. The chef was very attentive and knew precisely how to prepare my request for ricotta cheese and garlic oil on top of the pretzel-like crust of the stuffed meat pizza. At $27.99, it was definitely worth every penny. I highly recommend everyone give this specialty pizza a try!
Book a table now
Love this place. The food is always fantastic! I come every week to get food for band practice for me and my band friends and the food never disappoints. Try the cheesesteak on garlic bread or the mango chicken salad. Staff is very friendly and professional.
Catered my New Year's event and the food was fantastic! Luis was incredibly attentive and ensured everything was taken care of. I'll definitely be booking with them again for our future parties. Thank you!
The pasta is always fresh, and the sandwiches are incredibly tasty! Everything is consistently excellent. I strongly recommend giving the Cavatelli a try.
Raissa, Luis, and the other lady (I apologize for forgetting her name) are fantastic. Keep up the great work, everyone! Thank you!
Book a table now
The pizza, wings, and fries are amazing! This is definitely my favorite pizza spot!
Delicious food and fast, friendly service. Family friendly. We will be back!
Sausage Broccoli Rabe Melt Sandwiches
Cheese Steak Alfredo Specialty Pizza
Bacon Chicken Ranch Specialty Pizza
Eggplant Rollatini Specialty Pizza
Grilled Chicken Special Sandwiches
Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwiches
Sausage, Peppers Onions Sandwich
Buffalo Chicken Specialty Pizza
Eggplant Parmigiana Sandwiches
Chicken Conca Doro Sandwiches
