I have been to Goodfella 's pizza dozens of times when I used to live in the Orlando area almost 30 years ago, while attending the University of Central Florida and pursuing my Master 's Degree. Having grown up in New York City and Long Island New York, I have been to some of the best pizzerias in town. A friend of mine told me about Goodfella 's and that it truly was real authentic New York Style pizza. I was very skeptical at first, but after going there and trying their pizza, I was convinced. Goodfella 's pizza is as close to New York Style pizza as you will find in Orlando. I don 't know how they do it, but their pizza is absolutely and positively the best New York Style pizza that I ha...
Update: have visited restaurants twice after initial review. Both times service has left a lot to be desired First time it took over 15 minutes for waitress to take order. Other guests who arrived after me were waited on before me. Waitress finally came by after another waitress let her know I was waiting. Second time waiter forgot part of the order. Had to ask another waiter for bill to leave restaurant. Service quality has significantly declined from my experiences. It's a shame because their food is good. Food was great. Antipasto salad was nice and fresh. The meatballs were tender with just the right amount of spice for me. The almond cake was out of this world . Kudos to the chef.
As a diehard pizza fan I would argue they have the best pizza in all of Orlando. When I go with my family they get all kinds of other entrees and we always leave with to go boxes. Food is amazing, servers are incredible, and the vibe in the restaurant is super chill. Got 4 or 5 TVs with sports going on so it’s fun for the whole family.
I would give this place 10 stars if I could. The food is always amazing. My husband and I dine here regularly and are always up for recommendations by our regular server, Zachary. He has never failed us yet in his recommendations! Every time we try one, it becomes our favorite! Don’t miss having lunch or dinner at this gem!!!
Book a table now
The best pizza in all central Florida, the boys are the best chefs in town. The staff amazingly friendly. Thank you very much. Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $30–50 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Fried Calamari, Garlic Knots
The closest to Philly pizza that I can findSuperbly fresh ingredients too. Service: Take out Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza Parking space Plenty of parking Parking options Free parking lot
This place has the best Italian food, hands down. The specialties are always fantastic, pizza always delicious, and the service is always great. 100% would recommend everyone.
First time here and it was a good choice! Food was great and our server Tina was super sweet and took great care of us! Highly recommend and most definitely coming back!
Book a table now
The bruschetta and penne al vodka with shrimp were so good. The stuff pizza slices is good and affordable!
The food is amazing, atmosphere is great, if you are a veteran or military they have discounts.
