I have been to Goodfella 's pizza dozens of times when I used to live in the Orlando area almost 30 years ago, while attending the University of Central Florida and pursuing my Master 's Degree. Having grown up in New York City and Long Island New York, I have been to some of the best pizzerias in town. A friend of mine told me about Goodfella 's and that it truly was real authentic New York Style pizza. I was very skeptical at first, but after going there and trying their pizza, I was convinced. Goodfella 's pizza is as close to New York Style pizza as you will find in Orlando. I don 't know how they do it, but their pizza is absolutely and positively the best New York Style pizza that I ha...
This restaurant serves incredibly tasty pizza, and I highly recommend the meat lovers pie. You must try the Italian bread—it’s my favorite, even more so than their garlic knots! If you want to add some garlic flavor, they offer garlic oil for just $2. The bread is simply divine and melts in your mouth. The service is warm and welcoming, making you feel right at home. The staff is friendly and does their best to attend to everyone, even though there are usually only two servers for many tables. Dining here feels like enjoying a family dinner at home. I strongly recommend Goodfella's!
Been here once, loved everything about the place. Great food, great staff, and loved the fact it’s a place for a quick beer, as it is to bring my family for lunch! Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $1–10 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Sausage
Excellent Chicken piccata dish. Everything was served fresh and hot. Service was fast and efficient. The place hopped at a Thursday night, but the team worked to get everything we needed in time. This place is definitely worth a try when you're close.
Book a table now
This place has the best Italian food, hands down. The specialties are always fantastic, pizza always delicious, and the service is always great. 100% would recommend everyone.
First time here and it was a good choice! Food was great and our server Tina was super sweet and took great care of us! Highly recommend and most definitely coming back!
Ok pizza, but the ridiculous wait time isn't worth it at all. Much better options out there. Food: 2 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 3
Meal type: Dinner
Price per person: $10–20
Food: 4
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
Book a table now
This place has true NY pizza! I have never had a bad pie here. Their pasta is also great. Highly recommend.
The bruschetta and penne al vodka with shrimp were so good. The stuff pizza slices is good and affordable!
