Goodys Pizzeria Bayside

Without a doubt, the best wings I’ve ever had! I had never heard of this place before I met my wife. When we first started dating, she would always order pizza from here and would send me to pick it up since they didn't offer delivery. The restaurant is small enough that I can easily pass it and turn around at the next intersection to get back to it, but parking can be a bit limited. Their wings are absolutely massive, and the 40 Creek BBQ sauce is my new favorite flavor. The last time I went with my father while my wife, mother, and kids enjoyed some time at the park. We ordered six servings of wings, each weighing one pound, along with a large portion of fries, and the total came to nearly...

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

I was in Trenton for the weekend and chose to try a family-owned local restaurant instead of the usual chain pizza place. The prices here were a bit higher than at a chain, which was to be expected, and I anticipated a higher quality in return. Unfortunately, that wasn’t the case. The pizza was surprisingly small for the size of the order, and the toppings seemed to be lacking. Meanwhile, the wings appeared as though the sauce had simply been squirted from a bottle into the container. Given the prices, I would have preferred to go to a chain restaurant, which would have likely cost about 25% less for a more consistent quality.

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

I've been here many times and the food is usually great. However, today I was really disappointed because the blacksluvacki was so dry and tough that I could hardly chew it. I probably won't order it again.

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

Fantastic food, try to go here regularly as it's close to work. Can't beat the prices, and everything they make is always delicious. Highly recommend the Coney fries.

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

Great pizza, EVERY SINGLE TIME!!! I will drive the 10 minutes out of Belleville any day for this pizza. And the staff are always friendly.

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply