We happened to find this pizzeria while heading back to our hotel after dinner hours. Since we were very hungry, we decided to grab some pizza. To our surprise, it was quite good! We loved the crispy crust coated in cornmeal. The toppings were fresh and flavorful. We even returned the next day for more slices. The Margherita had fresh mozzarella and a tasty sauce, while the BBQ chicken was packed with chicken pieces, though it had a bit too much BBQ sauce for our liking. The pepperoni was simple yet delicious, with plenty of pepperoni slices.
I really enjoy the variety of thin-crust slices with a cornmeal base. They also have Sicilian slices available. The pizza isn't overly saucy, which I appreciate. The staff is both friendly and professional. While there are no pasta dishes on the menu, they do serve salads and garlic knots.
The pizza is great and the staff is friendly. The owner clearly takes pride in his team and customers. I appreciate when employees have each other's backs! I will definitely be returning to this restaurant. Please note that according to NYC law, they have the right to refuse service.
Ordered to have delivered to the hotel after a LONG travel day. It was awesome. Got the pepperoni pie with meatballs added and it was the perfect meal after a tiring day. Will probably stop by for a slice again before the holidays end.
Book a table now
I was impressed by the quality of this restaurant. The paprikas were delicious and I had no complaints. I will definitely be returning. The ingredients were fresh and the pizza was great. I highly recommend Gotham Pizza.
Nice little corner pizzeria with seating. Pizza was delicious. Family of 4 finished a large pie in minutes. Got an extra buffalo chicken slice afterwards too.
Sebastian was very helpful and their prices are very cheap! If you need a cheap lunch where the pizza is great, give them a try!
They were nice and the food was good. Not too pricey I mean. If you're in the area you should stop by.
Book a table now
A solid slice at a reasonable price. There's not much more to say—it's pizza!
Great flavor, fast service. It's worth every dollar paid.
Buffalo Chicken 12" Pizza With 1 Topping
Buffalo Chicken 16" Pizza With 1 Topping
Chicken Cutlet 16" Pizza With 1 Topping
Chicken Cutlet 12" Pizza With 1 Topping
Bbq Chicken 16" Pizza With 1 Topping
Margherita 12" Pizza With 1 Topping
Margherita 16" Pizza With 1 Topping
Vegetable 16" Pizza With 1 Topping
Vegetable 12" Pizza With 1 Topping
Pepperoni 12" Pizza With 1 Topping
