This is the best pizza in New Jersey! It's a relaxed and welcoming spot, and you can often see someone stretching the dough as you enter. The flavors consistently surpass expectations, thanks to high-quality ingredients like cheese, sauce, and fresh vegetables, all at reasonable prices. For vegetarians, their pizza is outstanding—even though I'm not vegetarian, it's my top choice. The combination of veggies is truly delightful. The restaurant is also kid-friendly, with plenty of fellow Jets fans around. Plus, there's a parking lot conveniently located right in front. The entire space is on one level, making it wheelchair accessible, but note that the hallway leading to the seating area can s...
The pizza was good, but I was taken aback by the prices. We ordered two plain slices and a small 20 oz soda, and the total came to $9.38! Seriously? I get that prices have risen, but this seems excessive. When I got home, I checked online and found that a large pizza costs around $16. I also discovered they have a daily special for two slices and a 16 oz soda for only $5.16! It would be great if they promoted this special in the restaurant or mentioned it when customers are ordering slices. That could really help draw in and keep more customers.
Ordered chicken francese and both pieces were very pink inside and without a doubt undercooked. I have to cook it before I can eat it. It also did not have much egg batter. I asked for spaghetti and got linguini (and I called in over the phone so you?dthink he would?ve told me they didn?t have regular spaghetti). In the past I got the chicken francese sub and it was great, butI wouldn?t order from here again after this today. It is not good chicken francese
The pizza from this place is incredible, but the biggest downside is that their hours aren't convenient for most people looking to order pizza. Often, my friends and I want to order pizza on a Friday night, and when we check this place as our usual spot, they're never open to take our orders. It's frustrating because we're willing to spend money on their pizza, but we just can't seem to place an order. The pizza is fantastic... when you can actually get it.
Book a table now
Had my first Hickory Pizza this past weekend and I think it's safe to say that I have a new favorite spot. This is the NY style pizza I remember eating as a kid. The crust was especially memorable, the slightest touch of sweetness, as if you're eatingfresh baked bread. Great cheese to sauce ratio, generous with toppings.
We love the pizza here and I eat gluten free. Yesterday there was a mix up with our order and they called my husband after he picked up our pizzas to say they made a mistake and would deliver the correct one. On top of that, they gave us a giftcertificate for the inconvenience. Great pizza and great service, thank you!
Great pizza pies we bought through a Chatham Hickory Cinema event, 2 doors down. They were perfect and were on time as promised. The event was a party for kids and they were kind enough to cut the large pizzas into 18 slices and provided all the plates and napkins needed. Perfect! Thank you!
If you are Black, your money isn't welcome here. The pizza is tasty, but it's 2023—money has no race. They're missing out. It's time to learn how to address their biases.
Book a table now
The pizza frequently arrives with the cheese sliding off one side. Although they are quick to send a replacement when this happens, I wish it wouldn’t occur so often.
Fantastic Pizza Experience: Takeout for Dinner Price Range: $50–$100
2 Slices Of Plain Pizza Medium Fountain Soda Special
Buffalo Chicken Fingers With Fries
Chicken Cheesesteak Special Sub
Meatball Peppers Parmigiana Sub
Sausage Peppers Parmigiana Sub
Tortellini Parmigiana Platter
Buffalo Chicken Finger Salad
Eggplant Parmigiana Platter
Chicken Fingers With Fries
Chicken Parmigiana Platter
