Joey's Pizza

Joey's Pizza - Table reservation

88-11 Dunning Rd, Middletown I-10940-2267, United States, 10940-2217 Reservation
4.2 /5
897 Reviews

"Pizza is wonderful and has great variety! Best if you get it fresh for lunch and the crust is perfect. I suggest dining in and taking the time to enjoy the atmosphere and savor the flavor!"

Details

Phone: +18453440880

Address: 88-11 Dunning Rd, Middletown I-10940-2267, United States, 10940-2217

Reservation, Booking

City: Middletown

Website: https://joeyspizzamiddletownny.com/

Opening hours

Monday: 10:00 -22:00

Tuesday: 10:00 -22:00

Wednesday: 10:00 -22:00

Thursday: 10:00 -22:00

Friday: 10:00 -23:00

Saturday: 10:00 -23:00

Sunday: 11:00 -22:00

Statistics

Dishes: 10

Categories: 5

Reviews: 897


Address

Show Map

Reviews

Duck

1/5

I normally don’t write reviews. But do to me currently not being able to leave the bathroom after having two slices of joeys pizza I will. My brother and I have been ordering from them for two months now. They started out OK but got worse and worse as time went on. The pizza takes forever to be done then they mess up the order and literally put all the pepperoni on one side of the pizza and didn’t even put fresh garlic on it. On top of that the sauce is super watery and the crust feels like it came from a school. Also ITS WAY TO EXPENSIVE. For this F tier pizza it should be like 5 dollars a pie. On top of all this the next YOU WILL be blowing out of both ends. First time I thought it was me...

John

5/5

Absolutely fantastic! This place serves amazing pizza, and the staff is incredibly friendly. Lou, the pizza chef who also doubles as a cook, brings 34 years of experience crafting traditional New York-style pizza and authentic Italian dishes. Whether you're in the mood for Chicken Francaise, pizza, or anything in between, you'll find something to satisfy your cravings. The prices are great, and the selection of specialty pizzas is outstanding. Let's show our support for local businesses, especially the small ones! Place an order today—you won’t regret it! Even better, stop by and enjoy your meal while the cheese is still bubbling!

K

3/5

I do not like their tomato sauce, which kind of makes the whole pizza all bad. The balls rolled in oil/butter and nuts are very good, but again, the sauce is the same as is on the pizzas. Clean, friendly, and very accommodating. Not a dine-in type of atmosphere as kitchen is overly exposed. Tons of choices of pizzas, lots of them are weird, like drizzled American cheese to add color and pattern?? Vegetarian options: Regular pizza offerings to put on a cheese one. Probably rennet cheese instead of microbial enzymes

Sareen

5/5

I dined at this restaurant on Thursday around noon and was assisted by a gentleman named Andy. I must say, I have never encountered such outstanding customer service before. I brought my children along, and Andy kindly cut their pizza into small squares for them, which was such a considerate gesture! It's the little things that really make a difference. Plus, the pizza is always fresh and never reheated. Book a table now

James

5/5

The pizza was delicious. We were traveling and found this by reviews. Kids loved the pizza. My wife also had frav diavolo made dairy free and it was great. They play music and I thought it was a little loud but it might just be that I'm getting old. Kids loved it. Dietary restrictions: Pasta was made dairy free at request.

Joshua

5/5

I happened to be in the area and my partner I needed to eat, so we stopped in here. This place had since of the best pizza I've eaten in a long, long time. I am extremely impressed. Stop in here if you're hungry and you enjoy delicious, thin crispy crust pizza. You will not be disappointed!

Amanita

5/5

I had a wonderful experience at this restaurant! The pizza is excellent, and the service is top-notch. I usually order the eggplant parmesan dinner, and it's absolutely fantastic. The portion sizes are generous, so you'll definitely have some leftovers for the next day. Highly recommended!

M

5/5

I truly appreciate the customer service at Joe's Pizza. I ordered the pepperoni pizza with extra cheese, and just seeing the gooey cheese was absolutely mouthwatering. It looked and tasted incredible. The sauce they use is what makes it perfect. Book a table now

Rick

5/5

Incredibly delicious pizza! We ordered a large cheese pizza and a 'small' eggplant, pesto, and ricotta for four people, and the slices were so generous that we ended up taking half of each pizza home. I highly recommend it!

Maya

5/5

Pizza is wonderful and has great variety! Best if you get it fresh for lunch and the crust is perfect. I suggest dining in and taking the time to enjoy the atmosphere and savor the flavor!


Dishes

Homemade Meatball Parmigiana Hot Hero
Homemade Meatball Parmigiana Hot Hero

Sausage Peppers Parmigiana Hot Hero
Sausage Peppers Parmigiana Hot Hero

Gluten Free Personal Plain Pizza
Gluten Free Personal Plain Pizza

Rigatoni Alla Vodka With Chicken
Rigatoni Alla Vodka With Chicken

Roman Style Baked Rigatoni Pasta
Roman Style Baked Rigatoni Pasta

Rigatoni Alla Vodka With Shrimp
Rigatoni Alla Vodka With Shrimp

Veal Cutlet Parmigiana Hot Hero
Veal Cutlet Parmigiana Hot Hero

Our Famous Rigatoni Alla Vodka
Our Famous Rigatoni Alla Vodka

Chicken Parmigiana With Pasta
Chicken Parmigiana With Pasta

Chicken Bacon Ranch Cold Hero
Chicken Bacon Ranch Cold Hero