"The owners and staff are super friendly. They have, by far, the best pizza around."
Phone: +15162563300
Address: 1056 Franklin Ave, 11580, Valley Stream, United States
Reservation, Booking
City: Valley Stream
Monday: 11:00-21:20
Tuesday: 11:00-21:20
Wednesday: 11:00-21:20
Thursday: 11:00-21:20
Friday: 11:00-21:20
Saturday: 11:00-21:20
Sunday: 11:00-21:20
Dishes: 10
Categories: 5
Reviews: 305
Owner changed the salad menu . Gorgonzola salad with grilled chicken used to have cranberries and walnuts, a good amount of salad greens and Gorgonzola. Changed to no cranberries and no walnuts, hardly any salad greens, less chicken and Gorgonzolaand tomato slices with the core. All this cut back and price raised! Will not be going back there!
The owner changed the salad menu. Gorgonzola salad with grilled chicken that are used to cranberries and walnuts, a good amount of salad green and gorgonzola. Walked on no cranberries and no walnuts, barely salad green, less chicken and gorgonzola and tomato slices with the core. All this cut back and price increase! It won't go back!
I waited an hour and a half for two sandwiches, even though I live just down the street. The grilled chicken wrap was burnt and inedible, and there was barely any egg on the pepper and egg hero. Unfortunately, I probably won’t be ordering from them again, which is disappointing since we try to support local businesses.
I ordered the calamari appetizer, but as soon as I opened it, I was hit with the unpleasant smell of frozen fish. It was inedible, so I ended up throwing it away. The pizza was just mediocre. This is the second time we've ordered from here, and it will definitely be the last. Book a table now
Really consistent quality. The Greek salad is pretty awesome. The only complaint is when we get toppings on half the pizza, the cutting is pretty uneven and my husband seems to always get much bigger slices, which is sad for me because the pizza is pretty darned good!
I ordered the lunch special, which featured ziti with sausage and peppers, for around $8. The food was both delicious and satisfying. The staff was polite and attentive. It's conveniently located within walking distance of LIJ Hospital, making it a great spot!
I ordered the calamari appetizer, but when I opened it, there was a strong frozen fish odor that was very off-putting. I ended up discarding it. The pizza was decent, but after ordering from John Anthony's twice, I can say this will be my last time.
I waited an hour and a half for two sandwiches. The grilled chicken sandwich was burnt and impossible to eat. The egg portion on the pepper and egg hero was very small. It’s disappointing, especially when we’re trying to support local businesses. Book a table now
I ordered the garlic Parmesan wings, but they were overcooked. The garlic bread with cheese also had too much cheese, which didn’t improve the experience. Overall, I felt like I wasted both my time and money.
The owners and staff are super friendly. They have, by far, the best pizza around.
245 Merrick Rd, Lynbrook, NY 11563, USA, United States
Reservation, Breakfast-brunch, American, Seafood, Coffee, Food
"Service: Dine in Meal type: Breakfast Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5"
428 Atlantic Avenue, Village Of East Rockaway, 11518, United States Of America
Reservation, Chocolate, Italian, Pizza, Lunch, Meat
"Excellent pizza! Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $1–10"
88 Atlantic Avenue, Village Of Lynbrook, 11563, United States Of America, Village of Lynbrook
Reservation, Italian Restaurant, Wine Bar, Pizza Place, American, Pizzeria, Italian, Pizza
"Excellent food, family environment and very reasonably priced."
83 Roosevelt Ave, 11581, Valley Stream, United States
Reservation, Mediterranean, Fast Food, Salads, Pizza, Greek
"I thoroughly enjoyed the delicious and fresh food. I will definitely be ordering from there again."
124 N Central Ave, 11580, Valley Stream, United States
Reservation, Chef B's, Seafood, Chicken, Curry, Juice
"Stale stale food reheated. Terrible Terrible nasty food. Food: 1"
