You will maybe be redirected
"Kelley's been out for our family for 20 years. Whenever we're in town, we'll eat here. I recommend the Greek salad and her homemade dressing. Service is always great."
Dishes: 18
Amenities: 3
Categories: 5
Reviews: 183
That's how I ordered from Kelley's pizzeria on November 20th and over Grubhub. I ordered the Sicilian Shrimp, Mini-Greek Salad and the Garlic Shrimp White Pizza. My order came when it was on Grubhub. The driver had to return to the restaurant because he forgot my pizza. I started with the shrimps and then moved to the salad. When I opened the pizza box, it wasn't the pizza I ordered. Instead, I got a chicken and artichoke heart pizza. That was very disappointing. I was looking forward to the garlic shrimp pizza. I spent about $50 on food. I would have given this a 5 star, but the wrong pizza was it. I will say, however, that the food was amazing. Except for the wrong pizza.
We just got home with our dinners, only a 2 mile trip. I tried to cut my eggplant parmigiana and couldn't do it so I looked at it and it was all burnt on the bottom. I called immediately and they said I could get a replacement, but I didn't feel like going back down. I said can't you just mark me in the book for my next trip. They said yes for 15% of my next parmigiana. That is unacceptable. I'm old and it's hard for me to get around, that's why I didn't go back down.
They have a wide variety of items on the menu including pasta, pizza, calzones, seafood, wings, etc. We had a small pizza which is indeed very small. Luckily I ordered salads the mini is huge so beware. It's enough for 2. The server was attentive and polite. We got our food fairly quickly. The atmosphere is comfortable. I'll have to come back to try something different.
Great food, love the dressing for the Greek salad and they don?t skimp on the toppings (aka not salad with an olive). It was my first time here, but I'm definitely back. Also ordered a side of garlic knot and they were also super delicious, with tons garlic
Kelley's been out for our family for 20 years. Whenever we're in town, we'll eat here. I recommend the Greek salad and her homemade dressing. Service is always great.
