Let's be clear, Little Vincent's can be a bit daunting for newcomers. You'll encounter a grumpy staff member who seems to lack patience, even during quieter times. The silver lining is that ordering a slice isn't complicated, and you really can't go wrong with it. A plain slice costs $2.25 and is delicious on its own, but for an additional 75 cents, you can request it with a generous layer of cold cheese on top. This option isn't advertised, so you'll need to ask for it directly. When you order two slices with the cold cheese, the cheese starts to melt slightly on the hot slice, creating a truly unique experience. Whether or not you choose this option is likely just a matter of personal pref...
Cheesehead2. T'aint the best pizza on long Island as many claim but , in my opinion it's the best pizza I have found in Suffolk County. When I'm in the area I always stop for a slice or two. Stick with the pizza. When I have ventured to their other offerings I have generally been underwhelmed. No, it's not that they are unappetizing but I have had better.
Very hit and miss. Used to be much better before the pandemic and price changes. Chicken Parm dinner used to be enough chicken for leftovers. In the last few years the prices have gone up but the portions have decreased. Sometimes the chicken is so thin it's 90% breading. Please increase your quality control.
Best pizza on long island. I went here practically everyday over the summer. there's nothing better than drunk pizza at 3 in the morning, and little vincent's does the trick. definitely try their cold cheese slice. and no, no garlic knots
Book a table now
I’ve been here many times. If you find yourself near Lake Ronkonkoma stop in for a slice even if you are not hungry. They make some of the better pizza I’ve had. It’s not the best but it’s damn good.
Outstanding pizza available at any hour, even at 2 or 4:20 AM! The secret lies in the use of top-quality ingredients, such as premium mozzarella cheese, among others.
This pizzeria is a bit expensive, but since they stay open until 2 or 2:30 in the morning, it's a go-to late-night spot for me when I'm in the area.
Absolutly outstandng pizza best on long island open till 2am on Sundays thru thursday open till 4 on saturday and Fridays
Book a table now
I was introduced to this gem about 15 years ago by a friend of mine.
Great pizza! Fabulous quality! We order from you guys all the time!
