Mama Carolla's

Mama Carolla's - Table reservation

1031 East 54th St, Indianapolis, Indiana, USA, 46220, United States
2432 Reviews 4.3

"I was looking for something different from the usual Italian fare and oh my goodness, they have the BEST lasagna and chicken parmesan. We will definitely be ordering again!"

Details

Phone: +13172599412

Address: 1031 East 54th St, Indianapolis, Indiana, USA, 46220, United States

City: Indianapolis

Website: http://www.mamacarollas.com/

Opening hours

Tuesday: 17:00-21:30

Wednesday: 17:00-21:30

Thursday: 17:00-21:30

Friday: 17:00-21:30

Saturday: 17:00-21:30

Statistics

Dishes: 10

Amenities: 24

Categories: 5

Reviews: 2432


Address

Show Map

Reviews

5 /5 Rating

During a recent trip to Indianapolis, we had the pleasure of dining at a charming Italian restaurant called Mama Carolla's. Located in a beautiful converted home in a retail/residential area, Momma Corolla's Italian Restaurant had larger rooms for groups and smaller rooms for families or parties. With a reservation made the day before, we were quickly seated and greeted by our friendly server. The cocktails, wine, bread, salad, and entrees were all prepared perfectly. We thoroughly enjoyed our dining experience at this family-owned restaurant, which truly captures the old Italian ambiance. We hope to return in the future and thank the owners and staff for their hospitality.

5 /5 Rating

My family introduced us to Mama Carolla's and we absolutely love coming here! My brother-in-law proposed to my sister here, so whenever we visit, we are surrounded by cherished memories. The food is consistently outstanding and the staff is attentive, friendly, and knowledgeable. They offer a great wine selection and a charming outdoor seating area.

5 /5 Rating

The food and service at this restaurant are consistently excellent. The Angel hair pasta is so light and delicious. The new Bomba dessert was amazing. I couldn't resist taking the ricotta cake home for a second dessert - it's perfectly sweet. I wish I could dine here every week.

5 /5 Rating

I truly think that this restaurant could be the top spot in town. Sitting on the patio, savoring delicious food and drinks, and receiving exceptional service at a fair price really sets this place apart from others. The mussels are absolutely fantastic!

5 /5 Rating

I was looking for something different from the usual Italian fare and oh my goodness, they have the BEST lasagna and chicken parmesan. We will definitely be ordering again!


Dishes

Chicken Involtine (Angel Hair Pasta)
Chicken Involtine (Angel Hair Pasta)

Chicken Piccata (Angel Hair Pasta)
Chicken Piccata (Angel Hair Pasta)

Veal Medallions (Mama's Favorite)
Veal Medallions (Mama's Favorite)

Eggplant Puttanesca (Spaghetti)
Eggplant Puttanesca (Spaghetti)

Veal Marsala Or Chicken Marsala
Veal Marsala Or Chicken Marsala

Chicken Parmesan (Penne Pasta)
Chicken Parmesan (Penne Pasta)

Salmon Filet (Papa's Favorite)
Salmon Filet (Papa's Favorite)

Sweetheart's Filet Oscar Style
Sweetheart's Filet Oscar Style

Chocolate Lava Cake A La Mode
Chocolate Lava Cake A La Mode

Chris's Homemade Ricotta Cake
Chris's Homemade Ricotta Cake