Request table reservation
You will maybe be redirected
"The primavera was great!"
Phone: (+1)6317518663,(+1)6317518840
Address: 212 Main Street, East Setauket, 11733, United States Of America
Reservation, Booking
City: East Setauket
Website: http://mariositalianrestaurantny.com
Monday: 11:00-12:00
Tuesday: 11:00-12:00
Wednesday: 11:00-12:00
Thursday: 11:00-12:00
Friday: 11:00-24:00
Saturday: 01:00-02:00 12:00-24:00
Sunday: 01:00-02:00 12:00-12:00
Dishes: 10
Categories: 5
Reviews: 1884
We placed an order totaling $260, and not a single item was correct. We ordered veal and received eggplant instead. The amount of oil at the bottom of that dish looked like they had emptied the fryer into it. We ordered a steakhouse salad but received no steak at all. We asked for pasta with vodka sauce and got pasta with red sauce instead. The issues just kept piling up. You would expect a restaurant to be diligent with such a large order, but that was not the case. To top it off, the chicken dish contained only one piece of chicken for $27—it's hard to believe. Never again.
Unfortunately, this restaurant is just a shadow of its former self. My wife and I decided to try it for the first time since the ownership change, and we won't be returning. The pizza had canned mushrooms, the mussels weren't fresh, and the primavera lacked any flavor, as did the Parmesan. Given the high prices, I expected much better quality. On a positive note, the portions were generous, and the French fries were tasty.
This restaurant offers incredible Italian food and excellent service. They stay open late, which is convenient. My family and I visit several times a month, and we’re always impressed. We typically order pizza, a pasta dish, or something with Parmesan, and we’ve never been let down. On our latest visit, they had a new dessert special: a cookie lava cake with a scoop of gelato, and it was absolutely delicious!
As a student at Stony Brook University, this has become my favorite spot to hang out with friends. It's conveniently located in town and stays open late. The food and drinks are fantastic, and the staff is incredibly friendly. Book a table now
The chicken parmesan lacked flavor, and the chicken itself was tough and chewy.
