Mario's Pasticceria

Mario's Pasticceria

199 E Main St, 11702, Babylon, US, United States
123 Reviews 4.7

"Been wanting to visit for quite some time and finally stopped in for a small box of cookies. They were simply amazing. The ricotta cookies were absolutely the best I have ever had. The lemon drop cookies were also outstanding. Great lemon taste without that thick sugary layer of icing too many have. I will most definitely be back to try some other items as soon as possible."

Details

Phone: (+1)6315398636

Address: 199 E Main St, 11702, Babylon, US, United States

City: Babylon

Opening hours

Tuesday: 08:00 -19:00

Wednesday: 08:00 -19:00

Thursday: 08:00 -19:00

Friday: 07:30 -19:00

Saturday: 07:30 -19:00

Sunday: 07:30 -17:00

Statistics

Dishes: 0

Amenities: 2

Categories: 2

Reviews: 123


Address

Show Map

Reviews

5 /5 Rating

A good Italian bakery has a unique smell. A sweet symphony of butter, vanilla and almond oil. That’s the first thing that greets you upon entering.The second is how spotlessly clean the place is.Next is the outstanding quality of their product. It’s hard to make a decision when you want everything.They have a variety of pastries, cookies, cakes, bread, and so onCranberry muffin was rich, not too sweet and loaded with plump cranberries.Brownie was an old school recipe made with walnuts, bitter chocolate, and butter instead of cocoa powder. The best I’ve had since forever.A classic almond horn dipped in quality dark chocolate, and a melt in your mouth apple tart with butterscotch aftertaste ma...

4 /5 Rating

Tried Mario's for the first time on St. Joseph's Day. Went there specifically for the Sfingi. Truly some of the best I've had. It's very easy to see when a place has the passion for what they do, because they take the time to do it right. The shell of the Sfingi was light, eggy and fresh as can be. The cannoli cream was velvety smooth and not overly sweet. Consistency was spot on. The cherry was there, the citron was there, the powdered sugar was there.... and it all adds up to perfection!Round trip for me was 1 hr. But I will definitely return for Easter for my grain pie!!!!Highly recommend this great establishment for quality that you will undoubtedly receive!!!

5 /5 Rating

My dad loves fruit tart cakes and they are very hard to find. I called this place on Father’s Day to try my luck and they said they could make it fresh for me and had it ready in half an hour. The people there are very kind and attentive and it is obvious to see that they want to give their customers a great experience. Their place is very clean and they have a lot of great other bakery treats. Overall 10/10 experience and will be coming here for future cakes and desserts!! It’s 25 minutes away from me but totally worth it nonetheless.

5 /5 Rating

This place is the best bakery I’ve been to in 50 years. I live 25 minutes away and drive past 3 others. I don’t understand how someone could have a bad experience here, much less how someone who supposedly did would waste their time bothering to write something negative. Just don’t go back and forget about rescuing the rest of us. A sad person who would be so unhappy in their own life that they hope to hurt a person who dedicates their life to working in their own business

5 /5 Rating

Been wanting to visit for quite some time and finally stopped in for a small box of cookies. They were simply amazing. The ricotta cookies were absolutely the best I have ever had. The lemon drop cookies were also outstanding. Great lemon taste without that thick sugary layer of icing too many have. I will most definitely be back to try some other items as soon as possible.