Masterson's Steakhouse Hilton Long Island Melville

Masterson's Steakhouse Hilton Long Island Melville

598 Broadhollow Rd, Melville, United States Reservation
2.1 /5
21 Reviews

"Friendly and not intrusive. Dinner and wine were well presented."

Details

Address: 598 Broadhollow Rd, Melville, United States

Reservation, Booking

City: Melville

Website: http://www.hiltonlongisland.com/

Opening hours

Unfortunately, the opening hours are not available at the moment.

Statistics

Dishes: 10

Categories: 5

Reviews: 21


Address

Show Map

Reviews

Famo

1/5

We had heard mixed reviews on Yelp, but since we lived in the neighborhood, we decided to give the restaurant a try. When we arrived, the place was empty, but gradually more people came in. We attempted to order a porterhouse for 4, but were informed that the restaurant had run out. We then asked for 2 porterhouses for 4, only to be told that they did not have that option either. The service was decent, and the restaurant was clean, but the food was not very good. We were disappointed with the quality, especially considering the high prices. We probably would not dine there again, even if we were staying at the hotel. We felt that for the same amount of money, we could have gone to a differe...

Loyce

0/5

We heard mixed reviews from Yelp, but as we lived in the neighborhood, we thought we would try the restaurant. The place was empty when we arrived, but people gradually came in. We ordered a porterhouse for 4. We were told that the hotel went out. The place was EMPTY! Then we asked for 2 Porterhouses for 4 neither. Then why did the waiter say? They had only single porterhouses. The service was fine. The place was clean. The food wasn't so good. I'm not even gonna eat there when I stay at the hotel. The place was far too expensive for the quality of food that was served. We could have gone to another steak house and paid the same amount, but would have a better meal. You would think that Hilt...

Kattie

0/5

I must preface this review by saying the last time we ate here it was very good. This time around I can't say the same. There was an issue with the soda system and all our soda were flat. It took a half-hour to find a server to replace them, an again the sodas were still flat. Well ok, these things happen. However I can not forgive the poor quality of the filet mignons. The steak had a strange taste and I did not eat more than 3 bites. The creamed spinach was absolutely foul. Shortly afterwards my stomach was not good to say the least. This restaurant had promise but unfortunately is off my list. When you are charging high-end steakhouse prices, you better deliver quality food.

April90066

4/5

From the wedge salad to the porterhouse steak, everything was prepared deliciously. The garlic mashed potatoes had so much butter they were decadent. The roasted asparagus was a little overcooked, but had a beautiful char and lovely flavor. Very good wine list with reasonable prices! Definitely worth eating at this restaurant when you're looking for a delicious steak dinner in a relaxed and beautiful environment. Book a table now

Hermina

0/5

From wedge salad to Porterhouse Steak everything was deliciously prepared. The garlic potatoes had so much butter they were decadent. The roasted asparagus was a little overboiled, but had a nice Char and beautiful taste. Very good wine list with reasonable prices! In any case, it is worth eating in this restaurant if you are looking for a delicious steak dinner in a relaxed and beautiful environment.

Jaqueline

1/5

from the keilsalat to the porterhouse steak everything was deliciously prepared. the garlic potatoes had so much butter they were decadent. the roasted asparagus was a little overcooked, but had a nice char and beautiful taste. very good wine list with reasonable trips! definitely worth eating in this restaurant when they look for a delicious steak dinner in a relaxed and beautiful environment.

Cookie

4/5

If you find yourself at the Hilton or in the surrounding area and are looking for excellent food, exceptional service, and a wonderful atmosphere, look no further. Make sure to visit Joe the bartender and say hello to Frank at the front desk - they will make you feel right at home and enhance your evening. The steak with the secret marinade was absolutely delicious!

Gia

0/5

If you happen to be in the Hilton, or in the area for this matter, and want a great food, a great service and a great ambience, don't look further.... They'll feel like home, they didn't make the evening better!! The secret marinade on the steak was delish! Book a table now

drkraf

4/5

The service at this restaurant is friendly and attentive without being intrusive. The meal and wine were both beautifully presented.


Dishes

Broiled 12Oz Maine Lobster Tail
Broiled 12Oz Maine Lobster Tail

Horseradish Bleu Cheese Butter
Horseradish Bleu Cheese Butter

Masterson's French Onion Soup
Masterson's French Onion Soup

Free Style Raspberry Napoleon
Free Style Raspberry Napoleon

Long Island Oyster Pan Roast
Long Island Oyster Pan Roast

Smoky Black Turtle Bean Soup
Smoky Black Turtle Bean Soup

Creamed Spinach With Garlic
Creamed Spinach With Garlic

Assorted Ice Creams Sorbets
Assorted Ice Creams Sorbets

New England Lobster Bisque
New England Lobster Bisque

Filet Mignon (8Oz Or 12Oz)
Filet Mignon (8Oz Or 12Oz)