I have two key observations about this family-owned restaurant: 1) The reviews from 4 to 6 years ago were actually worse than the more recent ones, indicating that the poor food and service are not just a result of Covid-related challenges. 2) They clearly show a lack of respect for delivery customers, frequently messing up orders—even for families ordering expensive dinner items or workers ordering lunch! If you dare to call and complain, they respond with an attitude and offer no apologies.
I ordered five items from Mother Kelly's in Rockville Centre. While the penne with butter sauce was decent, the other four were either poorly prepared or downright unappetizing. My appetizer, the so-ca...
Can’t give Mother Kellys enough praise. Tried it on a recommendation and was more than impressed. 3 of us ordered the Buffalo Cauliflower, Burnt Broccoli, Eggplant meatballs, Regular Meatballs, and the Shrimp in pasta with pink sauce. Quality of food was amazing and felt home made. The portions were amazing and we have left over for days! Owners were there and were so personable and felt invested in each patron. Provided both garlic bread and garlic knots which are absolutely the best in the area! Can’t wait to try more items on the menu!
Always a great experience! I'm a fan of the spinach pie and garlic knots. I ordered a chicken cutlet hero and some Italian wedding soup for a simple dinner, and there was more than enough to share among three people. I highly recommend this place for its friendly customer service and tasty food. The service is also quick!
Really though the food was so so. some things were good and some were pretty lousy. the garlic knots were raw dough in the middle. Chicken was waaaay overcooked. Pizza was good. Antipasto good. Seafood was a disaster oddly seasoned, not fresh, possibly canned/frozen? I dont think we’ll be back.
Book a table now
Mother Kelly’s is amazing. Delicious food with huge portions. Such nice owners and staff. When you walk in the door they make you feel welcomed. I couldn’t say enough good things about this place!
The pizza is excellent; I just wish it had a bit more flavor. Nonetheless, I would still give you five stars! I absolutely love the garlic knots, and the owners are incredibly nice!
This place is a must. Delicious homemade Italian food. Mother Kelly's has been around well over 40 years in the general area. Amazing food at reasonable prices!
Balsamic chicken is excellent, delicious. Large portions very welcoming staff and came with free extras! Garlic knots are the best we’ve had!
Book a table now
Amazing corn beef and cabbage! The best i’ve ever had! The owners are very friendly and very nice! Highly recommend this spot!
Good food, huge servings, and they always seem to something extra for no charge…..
