From 6:45 to 9:20, we spent our time calling, waiting, and messaging just to figure out the status of our order—whether the restaurant had even received it, if it was out for delivery, and when we could expect it to arrive. It was incredibly frustrating trying to track down our pizza. We were really looking forward to enjoying a nice evening together, but ended up mostly hungry and ultimately disappointed.
When the pizza finally arrived, it was completely cold. The wings were dry, barely had any sauce, and were mostly coated in black pepper. The mozzarella pinwheels were just unpleasant. To make matters worse, they forgot the two-liter soda we ordered. It's safe to say we will not be orderi...
I've ordered from this restaurant twice before, and it was fine. However, during my third order, they called to cancel it without providing any reason, which was quite frustrating, but I understand that things can happen. Reluctantly, I decided to give them another chance and placed a fourth order. After taking my payment information, my food never arrived, and I've called numerous times without any response. I wouldn't recommend ordering from this place; they really shouldn't be in business.
I’ve ordered pizza from Nicky’s several times, trying various toppings like pepperoni, sausage, peppers, onions, mushrooms, and olives. Every time, the pizza was cooked perfectly—well done with a thin crust. I also tried the whole cheesesteak with peppers and onions, and it was incredibly loaded with meat. The price was amazing; they could easily charge more, but I’m not complaining! Great job on the food, I’ll definitely be ordering again!
This restaurant is no longer in operation; it has been closed for several years. From what I understand, if you call this number, you're actually being connected to Olivio's in Little Silver. The location that used to be Nicky's is now occupied by Gigi's, which has its own Yelp page. I've also informed Yelp that Nicky's is closed.
Book a table now
As a long-time customer, I ordered take-out through Slice. I got two hot sandwiches, and unfortunately, the cheese was not inside the sandwiches; instead, it was stuck to the aluminum foil wrapping. This was very disappointing.
I ordered a whole chicken cutlet sub and you are not going to get the sub I got anywhere else. A whole loaf of Real Italian bread stuffed with cutlets.. they do it right !
Stopped here today for a pie. I have very high standards and let me tell you this pizza blew me away!!! Will definitely be back!!!!
The customer service was fantastic, and I enjoyed the delicious thin crust pizza from Nicky's, which I ordered from Olivia's!
Book a table now
Would highly recommend the sausage, pepper and black olive pizza! Best we ever had!
They have a Nice Thin Crust Pizza..
