This place has an old school feel to a pizza restaurant redefining Mom and Pop pizza shops. The menu here is also different than other pizza shops that alone is worth stopping in to check out not just the business itself but also the delicious smells the restaurant also emits. I also can't forget that this business serves alcoholic beverages! Wow! The only thing missing here are TVs, salad bar and an actual bar!!! The calzone was incredible. So was the fettuccine Alfredo. The sandwich was also absolutely incredible the Italian Beef. Courtney's Pizza to go was also fire. I also might recommend that the calzones, pizzas and subs and possibly the wings be well done for the best overall review....
I had a wonderful experience at the restaurant, thanks to the outstanding service from Bella. She was not only welcoming but also had a genuinely friendly demeanor. Upon my arrival to pick up my food, I was met with a warm smile, and she took great care of me throughout my visit. As for the food, it was amazing! I ordered a meatball sub, and I can honestly say it's one of the top ten best I've ever had.
Excellent and speedy delivery service! Today we finally enjoyed our meal in the restaurant. Karen was an outstanding waitress, and the other staff were friendly as well. It's a charming little spot with delicious pizza—perfectly cooked, not too greasy, and topped with fresh ingredients!
I had a fantastic dinner last night! I don't eat Italian food out much anymore since going gluten-free, but everything I had was delicious, from the garlic bread to my pasta. Our waitress, Tracy, was exceptional. I highly recommend Nicolo's Pizza!
Book a table now
We hosted a party there and it was fantastic! The staff was incredibly accommodating and friendly. The food was delicious, and many of our guests raved about the pizza salad. It was a hit!
I stopped by for an early dinner and had a fantastic experience. The pizza was delicious, and the beer was cold. I definitely plan to return to try their pasta and calzones! Thank you!
Megan makes the best Italian Margaritas! Pairs great with a GF crust Courtney (substitute the jalapeño for peperoncini).
Always a please to order delivery or sit inside and eat. Food is always on par along with service. Thank you!
Book a table now
The pizza was absolutely delicious, and the staff were very friendly and accommodating.
I love this place. The pizza is solid and delicious and the calzones are to die for!
