The Nutley Diner has a wonderfully friendly neighborhood vibe that truly reflects in the atmosphere of the place. While the staff can be a bit on edge and somewhat inattentive, the food arrives quickly, and the bill comes even faster. My experience with the Bagel Deluxe was somewhat perplexing, as it didn’t align with my expectations of what "Deluxe" should be. The bread was lukewarm, the toppings were served separately, resembling a salad, and I had to request cream cheese, which was provided in packets reminiscent of school lunches that you have to spread yourself. However, once I put my meal together, the salmon was very enjoyable. It had a lovely smoky flavor that, when paired with the r...
I had a fantastic experience at this diner! Our waitress, Carrol, was friendly and attentive from the moment we arrived until we departed. The food was fresh, hot, and served in a timely manner. I highly recommend this spot for brunch or a quick bite. The cream of broccoli soup was delightful, my chicken fettuccine Alfredo was excellent, and my girlfriend loved her cheesesteak without any toppings. I just wish I could have tipped Carrol more!
Dinner for two. I enjoyed a chicken, bacon, Swiss, and avocado sandwich with fries, while my companion had the three slider cheeseburger and disco fries appetizers. I drank a fountain Diet Pepsi. Everything was delicious. The staff was excellent, and the atmosphere was welcoming. Parking is decent, with some free spots and others requiring payment. We didn’t use the restrooms. Overall, a great place to eat.
This restaurant is excessively overpriced. The service is average, with the waiter hardly attending to us. The food is dry and lacking flavor. It's surprising that they can ruin a classic burger. I also advise against the onion soup; it was one of the worst meals I've ever had. I do not recommend this place and will not be returning.
Book a table now
Food was ok at best. Home fries was not cooked or browned enough, I could still taste the raw potato. Waffle was not crispy or not even browned. Very hard to flag someone down for a coffee refill. With all that, it's not cheap!
The salad was delicious and definitely worth the price. The waitress was fantastic—very polite, knowledgeable, and attentive, regularly checking in to make sure we were satisfied.
The diner experience was decent. The food was good, and we tried several breakfast options. The place was quite busy, and the parking lot was a bit cramped.
The waiter was extremely friendly and attentive, even making an effort to accommodate a substitution request. Additionally, the restroom was clean.
Book a table now
The service on Uber Eats was incredibly fast and efficient. Thank you!
The food was excellent. I will definitely try other items on the menu.
Chicken Tenders With French Fries
Grilled Chicken And Avocado Club
Buffalo Crispy Chicken Sandwich
Barbecue Pulled Pork Sandwich
Bacon Cheeseburger Quesadilla
Deluxe Grilled Turkey Burger
Deluxe Wild Mushroom Burger
Chicken Teriyaki Dumplings
Goat Cheese And Beet Salad
Deluxe Avocado Bleu Burger
