If I were to spin a tale of unexpected discovery and gastronomic delight, NY Bagels would take center stage. Picture me: lost in a sea of plazas, zigzagging like a mouse in a maze, on a quest to find the fabled Bagel of Everything. My destination? A location as elusive as the bagel's recipe itself.Then, as if scripted in a plot twist, the X on my treasure map was a... gas station? My heart did a little comedic double take, expecting fuel pumps and air fresheners. But lo and behold! Attached to this temple of transportation was a restaurant, its sign shining like a lighthouse NY Bagels. It was as if the gods of gastronomy themselves had decided to crash the most unexpected of venues.Finally,...
I usually enjoy this place even though I’ve been charged multiple different prices every time anywhere from 10.60-17.13 sad thing is I order the same dam bagel chips and orange juice every time I’m a man of habit .. last time I was in there put egg on my bagel no where did I ask for that usually I’m pretty understanding you see new staff in there all the time but the same gentleman working kind of gave me a attitude . I’m good plenty of choices instead of the one on 5001 gateway I never complained about the prices always going up and down but I’m good guess he’s rich man doesn’t need my business
This mom and pop, hole in the wall, bagel shop is a hidden gem. The bagels are as close to New York as you're going to get in Florida. They also have many items that northeasterners will love like junior's cheesecake. The staff is extremely friendly, and they sometimes serve really good pizza. Well, the pizza is always good but it's not always on the menu. I highly recommend this place for anybody who is craving a New York bagel.
The bagel tasted good, but the guy making it had only one glove on but used both hands to make it. Had his unloved fingers all the cream cheese. He also wanted to charge another $9 to add lox after I already paid $8 and ordered a “plain bagel with plain cream cheese and lox”. He said I needed to order Nova salmon. I’m not interested in a $16 bagel. Unsanitary and a rip off.
Book a table now
Great little bagel place. Stopped by twice while doing a weekend at Disney in Orlando. The tint on the windows will make the place look closed because it's so dark from out outside, but don't miss out on this place. Bagels delicious, service from staff was great. Price very reasonable.
This was an amazing place to stop at in Orlando! Super fast and great bagel recommendations by the woman working! The Asiago bagel with cheddar/bacon cream cheese was AMAZING! Also the Asiago bagel with tomato cream cheese and add bacon (WAS AMAZING)!
This is a hidden little gem in orlando. Bagels are fresh, cream cheese was good and the SEC SPK on an everything was legit. Highly recommend. Don't let the gas station fool you.
The Bagels are soooo good and they will put them in the oven if they have run out and it only takes 5mins. My favorite is the New Yorker!!
Book a table now
I just got a simple bagel and coffee. Bagel is how I like it, a soft crunch outside and chewy inside, and coffee is strong.
Fast service, great ny style breakfast bagel sandwiches. The facility was very clean and the people were friendly.
