Request table reservation
You will maybe be redirected
"Delicious ice-cream and friendly staff. A must have if you're around this area."
Phone: (+1)6316693020
Address: 1025 Straight Path, West Babylon I-11704-3246, United States
Reservation, Booking
City: West Babylon
Website: https://www.facebook.com/stoehrersoldfashionedicecream/
Monday: 12:00 -22:00
Tuesday: 12:00 -22:00
Wednesday: 12:00 -22:00
Thursday: 12:00 -22:00
Friday: 12:00 -22:00
Saturday: 12:00 -22:00
Sunday: 12:00 -22:00
Dishes: 4
Categories: 5
Reviews: 750
I am approaching 50 years old, and I will always cherish memories of my grandfather bringing us to this restaurant in the back of his pick-up truck, or my father stopping by to pick up secret sunflowers on his way home from work. Years later, my friends and I would ride our bikes here to grab a delicious treat. I also brought my own children here for a sweet treat on hot summer nights as they got older. Now living in North Carolina, I dearly wish I could quickly return for some old-fashioned ice cream. Sitting here, I reminisced about this place and felt relieved to see that it survived the pandemic, unlike many other businesses. I am so happy that you are still here! I hope to come back hom...
The ice cream at this restaurant is amazing! I have been a loyal customer for years and can't get enough of their fresh flavors. The service is always quick and friendly, with all the staff being incredibly beautiful. My favorite flavor is the chocolate oreo with whipped cream and cherry on top. I highly recommend trying it out next time you're in the area.
Yum! I tried the ice cream with hot fudge sundae style and it was delicious. It brought me back to Stewart's Ice Cream, which is the best in the Northeast. I'm happy I don't have to wait until I go upstate to enjoy such tasty ice cream!
This restaurant has been family owned and operated for 50 years. They make their ice cream fresh daily on the premises. Be sure to try the Grape Nuts ice cream...trust me, it's surprisingly delicious. Book a table now
The restaurant has a welcoming staff, a tidy atmosphere, and serves up mouthwatering ice cream that will have you craving for more. To be honest, it's my go-to spot for a sweet treat.
Old fashioned Ice Cream is the best Ice Cream that i have ever had! I have been going to them for 50 years and they haven't changed!
Cute friends theme.But the ice cream is WAY too sweet!!. A 20% reduction is necessary to save us from diabetes!!!
My fave spot recently. Love the Central Perk ice cream.Also enjoyed some Cookie Monster ice cream. Book a table now
Best ice cream on Long Island. They have so many flavors that I can’t really choose one.
Delicious ice-cream and friendly staff. A must have if you're around this area.
