We got an ice cream cake for a party. The pre-made ones are chocolate on bottom and vanilla on top with cookie crumbles in between. If you want different flavors you need to order in advance. They also have hard ice cream to scoop. And soft serve, about 4 flavors everyday. When we were there only one machine was ready. They're know for their Pineapple whip soft serve. Will go back for that.
Old Fashioned Ice Cream
1025 Straight Path, West Babylon I-11704-3246, United States Reservation"Delicious ice-cream and friendly staff. A must have if you're around this area."
Details
Phone: +16316693020
Address: 1025 Straight Path, West Babylon I-11704-3246, United States
Reservation, Booking
City: West Babylon
Opening hours
Monday: 12:00 -22:00
Tuesday: 12:00 -22:00
Wednesday: 12:00 -22:00
Thursday: 12:00 -22:00
Friday: 12:00 -22:00
Saturday: 12:00 -22:00
Sunday: 12:00 -22:00
Statistics
Dishes: 10
Categories: 5
Reviews: 982
Address
Reviews
Wide variety of icecream to choose from. Clean place and super friendly staff. They make these awesome icecream pies that are a-mazing! No place to sit and chill but plenty of parking in the back lot. Right off main road on Straight Path.
Yum! I tried the ice cream with hot fudge sundae style and it was delicious. It brought me back to Stewart's Ice Cream, which is the best in the Northeast. I'm happy I don't have to wait until I go upstate to enjoy such tasty ice cream!
This restaurant has been family owned and operated for 50 years. They make their ice cream fresh daily on the premises. Be sure to try the Grape Nuts ice cream...trust me, it's surprisingly delicious. Book a table now
The restaurant has a welcoming staff, a tidy atmosphere, and serves up mouthwatering ice cream that will have you craving for more. To be honest, it's my go-to spot for a sweet treat.
Old fashioned Ice Cream is the best Ice Cream that i have ever had! I have been going to them for 50 years and they haven't changed!
Cute friends theme.But the ice cream is WAY too sweet!!. A 20% reduction is necessary to save us from diabetes!!!
My fave spot recently. Love the Central Perk ice cream.Also enjoyed some Cookie Monster ice cream. Book a table now
Best ice cream on Long Island. They have so many flavors that I can’t really choose one.
Delicious ice-cream and friendly staff. A must have if you're around this area.
Dishes
Book a table now
Categories
-
Ice Cream
-
Chocolate
-
Seafood
-
Asiatic
-
Grocery
Amenities
-
Wheelchair Accessible
-
Accepts Credit Cards
- Reservation
Post Office Cafe
130 W Main St, 11702, Babylon, United States
Reservation, American, Seafood, Chicken, Coffee, Cafe
"Very noisy. Before you go, call and ask if there is a party Wheelchair accessibility: Good, but you need to use a certain entrance"
Subway
282 Higbie Ln, 11795, West Islip, United States
Reservation, Sandwiches, Chicken, Salads , Salad, Meat
"Tried to use deal and the worker wouldn’t let me use it"
Panera Bread
1025 Montauk Hwy, West Babylon, United States
Reservation, Sandwiches, Desserts, Salads, Pizza, Soup
"There was always a great experience. The staff is very friendly."
Casa Del Campo
1155 Deer Park Avenue, North Babylon, 11703, United States Of America
Reservation, Delivery Services, North American, Fast Food, American, Asiatic
"Single guy came to bar got served asap drinks and food was on point overall had a great experience"
Arby's
100 Sunrise Hwy, 11757, Lindenhurst, United States
Reservation, Delivery Services, North American, Fast Food, American, Lunch
"Food is good. Service is not always the best. Several times my order was wrong or food was missing from the bag. They were courteous with correcting orders."