Old Stone Market - Table reservation

It’s hard to decide what’s best here, but I guarantee you won’t find better scones elsewhere; the English cream in particular. The list of delicious foods goes on. We tried almost everything: the chicken cutlets, crispy yet juicy; the soups, particularly the Mexican one they have, and I don’t exaggerate when I say I could eat that for lunch and dinner three days back to back; the lasagna and the chicken pot pie are full of flavor with the unmistakable taste of homemade cooking. The cheese cake is to die-for and the rice pudding became a ritual for us when we are in Amagansett. If you are around, and haven’t discovered this place, GO!

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

This is a jewel of a market! Great for picking up ingredients or things you need for an impromptu picnic or dinner. Lunch is great! Empanadas are so good. But I really came here to rave over the peanut butter cookies. If you get them when they are fresh, do not walk.

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

Fabulous food, nice friendly service. The owner Vicky is a wonderful cook. Your baked goods are delicious and always fresh. If you're in the area, check this place. A short stop for good food and the market has a little everything.

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

Bacon Egg and cheese on a keizer role. Simply over is often a challenge and this place lived up to my messy eggs sandwich expectations. The refrigerator had some interesting offers, as shown in my published photo.

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

Really great house made food, great selection of baked goods. Small business with a strange layout, but juicy and cozy. The staff is not always the kindest, but otherwise a good stop.

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply