Panatieri's has been providing top notch food for our company for the past couple of years. Joe and his team have been very accommodating to our corporate needs; but just as important...the food has been nothing short of tasting amazing! Thepresentation of the hoagie trays to the baked dishes, even down to the great tasting pizza. It's also nice to stop in for lunchto see Joe, say hello, and get some hot pizza slices. I would recommend Panatieri's Pizza to anyone in the Flemington area ifyou're looking for great service and even better tasting food.
There's no need to look anywhere else! You won't find a better restaurant than this one. The pizza is the best in town, and every item on the menu is exceptional. I'm excited to see the new renovations once they're finished! Be sure to tell Joe that Reverend Harry sent you!
We regularly get food and have done catering a few times now, everything is always fantastic. Joe, his family and team are great. You really get what you pay for and quality is number one here. Good food makes a good party and they nailed it. Thanks!
By far, the best pizza in the area! Need to give these guys credit for raising the bar. I've been to Panatieri's pizza four times now to get a slice or two on my way home from work and was pleasantly surprised each time.
Book a table now
I took a pic of what was left of the works pizza. Always get a great meal here. The sauce is always balanced and slightly spicy, they don’t use a ton of cheese and the crust is perfectly cooked slightly sweet.
Great food. Pizza and sandwiches are always good. I have also gotten food catered from Panatieri's and it was Excellent. They have good honey mustard here as well.
Best italian food in Flemington with the nicest owners! Their vodka sauce is top notch! Will definitely return!
My favorite ???? place around! The Frank has become my new favorite pie ????
Book a table now
Panatieri’s is our go-to for amazing pizza! The service is always great.
One of the best cheesesteaks that I ever had….and I have had a few.
