I ordered a pizza for delivery today through your preferred app, Slice, which was actually delivered by DoorDash. The app sent a push notification saying my food had been delivered, but it hadn't arrived yet. When I spoke to Slice customer support, they told me that the app automatically generates that message for time-stamping purposes and that they couldn't contact the driver. Even though I included my room number in the delivery instructions, the driver claimed he didn't have that information. I’m not sure what role Slice played in my order other than imposing a mandatory tip service fee. I could have just ordered directly from DoorDash since they were the ones making the overpriced deliv...
The same lady who handed me my order answered the phone and told me they didn’t have the Sicilian pizza. I had placed my order more than an hour ahead of time, so this was frustrating. She implied that they didn’t want to make the pie, and when I pointed out that there was a price difference, it took me several times of repeating myself before she said she would look into it.
Additionally, the tres leches cake was also disappointing; it was overly thick and not appetizing at all. This will definitely be my last time ordering from this place. If there’s going to be a change in my order, I expect to be notified right away. A simple text or call would have been appreciated, and I would have ra...
Panatieri's Piscataway stands out with an extensive selection of slices, including standout options like Cheesesteak and Buffalo Chicken. While some slices might lean towards the drier side, a simple request for extra sauce easily elevates the experience. The diverse range of choices, from Sicilian to sausage or meatball, ensures there's something for everyone. Despite potential lunchtime crowds, the variety and unique touch Panatieri's brings make it a worthwhile dining experience. Parking: Plenty of parking
The Giant Pizza Slice is filling, tasty, and a great for the price. Disappointed in the sausage, peppers and onions calzone. It was just a big ricotta ball with scarce slivers of sausage, peppers, and onions that are playing hide-and-seek. The mild Buffalo wings were saucy, juicy, and finger licking good!Quality has changed over the past few months. Not sure if there was a change in ownership, management, or cooks.
Book a table now
Paid $30 for a large Stromboli and Snapple. Picked up the box to leave and the box was flimsy and couldn’t hold the weight of the sauce container they put inside and the large Stromboli so it bent and the food and sauce container fell on the floor. They refused to make another one. The woman saw the box bend. Just poor service. Me and my family won’t ever order from here again.
Small town pizzeria with big city pizzeria attitude (in the price department)! Pizza is good but $5/slice is too much for anywhere in Jersey unless you have some truffle hidden under the cheese, which I doubt. Slices are thin crust (I like) so if you usually eat two, here you’d need minimum of 3 slices to be full.
Small town pizzeria with big city pizzeria attitude (in the price department)!Pizza is good but $5/slice is too much for anywhere in Jersey unless you have some truffle hidden under the cheese, which I doubt.Slices are thin crust (I like) so if you usually eat two, here you’d need minimum of 3 slices to be full.
In my opinion, this is the best Panatieri's location. The food is delicious, and the servers are friendly. The space is clean, bright, and beautifully kept. It has a genuine mom-and-pop vibe, and you wouldn't even realize it's part of a local chain.
Book a table now
I have ordered a few items on their menu from a few visits and every time I’ve been completely satisfied. The lady that takes the orders is very sweet and friendly. I think I found my new fave piscataway pizza spot.
I was very hungry and I got a pizza for breakfast. And the pizza was amazing. And a nice big slice. Love big slices of pizza.
Chicken Roll Eggplant Roll Pepperoni Roll Sausage Roll
Pepperoni Sausage Ham Mushrooms And Mozzarella Cheese
Cavatelli And Broccoli In A Garlic And Oil Sauce
Chicken Fingers And Mozzarella Sticks
Portobello Mushrooms Roast Pepper
Mozzarella And Ricotta Cheese
Fresh Mozzarella And Tomato
Pepper Onion And Mushrooms
