We had heard of this establishment sometime ago but finally made our way over here for dinner/lunch on two consecutive days. The first day we ordered their large supreme pizza with two large sweet refillable while dining in teas. We did thin crust. The service was friendly/prompt. The pizza came out timely, and it was quite good. It could've perhaps used a few more toppings out to the edge of the pizza, and it ate a little dry; it seems as though the thin crust was not the way to go with this one but a thicker crust would've been better with the additional toppings. However, once we got some of their marinara sauce and added to the pizza it really improved it, so much so that we were willing...
Hubby and I decided to go for the supreme thin crust. My first four jobs were in pizza so I'm kind of difficult to impress. I as impressed! The crust was thin and cracker crisp which is super difficult to make right as a supreme with all the moisture in the fresh toppings. We decided the perfect amount of sauce and toppings were on this pizza in order to achieve that crisp crust... but we needed a side of marinara to balance the bite. No problem they brought it right out! We live not far from Baldwin and we have struggled mightily to find good food nearby. This place is frequented by the locals and we delayed deciding to give it a try far too long. But like I Said I'm a pizza snob so I wasn'...
We recently tried the takeout dinner option at this restaurant, and were thoroughly impressed. The price per person falls between $10 and $20, which is very reasonable for the quality of food and service. We rated the food a 5 out of 5, as well as the service and atmosphere. One of our recommended dishes is the Vegetarian Pizza with Bacon - a unique and delicious option that we will definitely be ordering again.
My wife got the eggplant parmesan. It was unedible disgusting. My son got the chicken parmesan and the chicken was a pre-fried Frozen piece of chicken that you get at the grocery store. I got the calzone that's in the picture and I got about four more bites into it and couldn't eat it anymore. The staff was good and attentive and friendly.
Book a table now
I'm glad I decided to make the short journey from the Loves truck stop because parking is extremely limited. The service for takeout dinner was excellent, with a rating of 5 out of 5. The atmosphere was pleasant, with a rating of 4 out of 5. Prices per person were in the $20-30 range. I recommend trying the calzone!
Papa Sean's offers some of the best pizza and service in the area. The staff is friendly, knowledgeable, and attentive, and the food is truly delicious. Every bite is bursting with flavor, making it the top choice for pizza lovers. The service is quick and efficient, perfect for a take-out dinner option.
Excellent service, despite arriving shortly before closing the premises we were treated with kindness and respect. I recommend it. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
The pizza sauce at this restaurant definitely needs improvement. We ordered a pepperoni pizza and it had no flavor at all. I'm not sure what's going on, but I really hope they make a change.
Book a table now
Best pizza around and never disappoints. I’ve been eating from here for more than 10 years and never a bad experience. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
Pizza was delicious. I wish they had a larger size. Price was a little high but I guess everything is super expensive these days.
Chicken Breast Strips, Melted Cheese
Garlic Cheese Toast (3 Pieces)
Specialty Toppings Additional
Bbq Bourbon Chicken Salad
Specialty Pizza Stromboli
