Ordered two Prime Rib brunch for my Father for Father's day. It was supposed to be delivered between 10-11:30am. It's already past 1pm and my father still hasn't received the meal. Their ordering website said it was delivered already. My dad checked outside and his neighbors place, but nothing was received. I've been trying to contact the restaurant via phone call and email the past hour, but nothing. I got this recommendation from a friend, but I will definitely never try this place out again. Thanks for ruining me and my dad's Father's day! What a horrible first time experience.
Take-out dining from Pappo tonight was the highlight of our day! Food was fresh with the usual quality ingredients. Started with mushroom soup and butter lettuce salad. Entrees were JP Salmon filet with a fragrant chimichirri sauce and pasta Bolognese. Bread pudding with caramel sauce to share for dessert. Portions were generous and easy to heat and plate. Pre-paid by phone and our meal was delivered curbside with a smile and a heartfelt thank you. Candlelight dinner for two at home!
Pappo's new menu that was posted for Takeouts listed two of our favorite dishes, Cioppino and Burrata. We ordered those via email the night before we went in. Their Takeout times are between 3:00 and 6:00 PM. When we went in, they were friendly and well organized. We enjoyed a glass of wine and great conversation. That evening we enjoyed a great Pappo's dinner aboard our boat. Cioppino and burrata were excellent. I highly recommend Pappo's fine Takeout dining.
Wonderful salmon, the best key lime pie I have ever eaten, very taste full peach cobbler with accompanying whipped cream. Garlic bread was good, though infusing the butter with the garlic would have made it even tastier. The melon con jamon the 3 pieces of melon still had the rind on, which made it difficult to eat, and wow was it salty but we did enjoy it. Great service the bag was ready when I arrived a little after 4pm, ready to go. We'll be back!
Book a table now
The menu has been updated and no longer features many of the dishes shown on Yelp. The new menu is limited and underwhelming. The lamb dish was disappointing and overpriced, with some parts being too charred. The pasta was hard to eat and overall not very tasty.
Excellent restaurant in normal times. We ordered take out this afternoon and took home yummy cioppino, burrata and toast. Support our wonderful local restaurants during this pandemic!
The food at this restaurant is fantastic and the cocktails are delicious. The staff is friendly and I would definitely recommend this place and I will definitely be going back again.
Love Pappo, the cocktails are always awesome and their burger is the best on the island. I also love dining in and look forward to returning!
Book a table now
Delicious dishes made with fresh, seasonal ingredients. Perfect for a romantic evening or a gathering of close friends.
There was quick, helpful, and friendly service. This place has a great design.
Corvina-Rondinella, Antica Cantina, Amarone Della Valpolicella'08
Pinot Gris- Reisling, 'Edlezwicker, ' Dirler-Cade, Alsace '11
Sangiovese, 'Il Macchione ' Vino Nobile Di Montepulciano '08
Moscato D 'Asti, 'S. Maurizio, ' Forteto Della Luja '12
Pignoletto, Fattoria Monticino Rosso, Emila-Romagna '11
Brachetto Passito 'Pian Sogni ' Forteto Della Luja '08
Syrah, Stage Left Cellars, Santa Lucia Highlands '10*
Valley Ford Cheese Co. Estero Gold (California, Cow)
Cabernet Sauvignon 'Reserve ', Blacksmith, Napa '09*
Grenache-Syrah, 'Chateauneuf-Du-Pappo ' Sonoma '09*
