Although I haven't been into the shop, I can only imagine that the Atmosphere matches the calm and pleasing demeanor of the co owner that I had the pleasure of meeting today. The cookies themselves are amazing! Their Snickerdoodles are now my #1 go to.On a side note...the co owner was in my place of employment, which deals with the public, taxes and automobiles. She was pleasant, patient and very understanding. And AFTER waiting for her turn for over 2 hours, she left after conducting her business, AND THEN came back with cookies for me and my coworkers who were all very touched by such a gesture. So....Thank You Penny and Pearl's! You gained some cookie eating customers today!
We tried a variety of their cookies, and they were all absolutely delicious! It’s tough to choose a favorite since every flavor was fantastic, including crème brûlée, brown butter snickerdoodle, peanut butter cup, lemon butter, and brookie. The cookies were also nicely packaged for our journey home. The service was both friendly and quick.
The cookies here are incredible. This has become our new favorite place. We haven't encountered a bad cookie yet. We enjoy exploring new flavors, but we always make sure to pick up some classic chocolate chip cookies, no matter what!
absolutely magnificent. you cant go wrong here. my cousin bought me a chocolate chip cookie sandwhich and its the best thing i have eaten for dessert in a long time. i cant recommend this spot enough!!!!
Book a table now
Amazing cookies. This is our new favorite spot. Haven’t had a bad cookie here. We love trying new flavors but always make sure to grab a few classic chocolate chips no matter what!
By far the best cookies in Louisville!! You can never go wrong with a snickerdoodle from Penny Pearl’s.
best cookies in louisville such a hidden gem and i love supporting small businesses!!
The baked goods here are outstanding. You can't go wrong with any selection you make.
Book a table now
Delicious cookies! So many options it’s hard to choose. Will be back!
Best cookies ever!
